scottishjohn
Members-
Posts
4259 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
21
Everything posted by scottishjohn
-
Commercial property build?
scottishjohn replied to Sjk's topic in General Self Build & DIY Discussion
In scotland we could split the police station and make it into units --which would be rated seperatly --so you could let off other bits --or not --but rates would only be on what you used -
another price for ICF --velox system to give 0.15 walls £50 sqm I should clarify that is just the wall value not including exterior or interior finishing which of course will drop it some more
-
yes i have 8 zone valves on my system and they were all danfoss --all failed same way at least once in last 15 years --micro switch every time the load rating is too low on them to be turning on a big pump --so yes don,t use danfoss --after changing lots i changed make of units --problem stopped
-
Anybody using Velox ?
scottishjohn replied to Tim Alsop's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
tlaked to the man from velox and it does look like a good system for the self builder , costing seem less than durisol and comparable and cheaper than some poly icf types --but looks much stronger could be alot cheaper by time you looked at poly bracing system and costs and would seem to be as flexible as your imagination for shapes you can do . also the floor system is attractive for basements /garages under living accomdation still looking for the downsides If you know any don,t be shy -
The POSIs Picnic: a solution is in sight.
scottishjohn replied to ToughButterCup's topic in General Construction Issues
both solutions will work well as when it is finished and floor attached to both wallplates and joist it is basically a solid lump thats why your engineer is not worried about full support on the end of the joist ,cos the load is spread over all components joists ,wall plates and floor itself and the load path is directly up the vertical brace into top stringer of the joist ,the actual load on the end will be very little as it is not braced and will bend to a degree and transfer the load up the vertical path of the brace that is there --If it was designed to be strong enough to start with the ends trimmed off its not on a wing where things are deflecting and bending all the time ,where a solid unit will just fracture -stresses are totally different . I give up --you all want to make it more complicated than it really is ,the making up of end fitments will take much more time and effort than a simple doubling up of beam and more bolts to wall do what ever you like -
The POSIs Picnic: a solution is in sight.
scottishjohn replied to ToughButterCup's topic in General Construction Issues
it will be minimal but to be super sure i said double up on bolts and if ends of joists are packed after fitting they can go nowhere --no space means even if there is a twisting force it can,t move cos theres no where for the plates to go. Isaw original spec was one bolt every 600 but joist were 400 spacing --i would have done bolts at same as joists anyway ,and if you still worried about something that can,t happen apply a layer of no nails or whatever behind wall paltes then load is pread over total area how many diff solutions do you want to a simple problem i suggested a soltion to fix it that way aswell take your pick both will work fine and with double wall plates you got twiice the area to glue + double screw the floor too if you want engineers have said you don,t need full support on the end of the joist anyway --so can,t be much load anyway--=if you believe them me igo for belt and braces always -
The POSIs Picnic: a solution is in sight.
scottishjohn replied to ToughButterCup's topic in General Construction Issues
this is why isuggested if you really want to over engineer it to use plywood and glue a few layers together and jigsaw to exact shape ,then a bit of goorilla glue and predirlled holes +screws make it bullet proof. so many simple ways to sort this problem and by the time the floor is glued+screwed its going no where. If you get floor bounce ,then your engineer didn,t spec it right to start with -
The POSIs Picnic: a solution is in sight.
scottishjohn replied to ToughButterCup's topic in General Construction Issues
we seem to be getting a bit anal now--next your going to tell me you used a torque wrench on all the thunderbolts -- 16m thunderbolts should be 100nm before you ask not that i,m a fan of them --used too many bolting down ramps and things in a garage -very critical on pilot size and do not like being taken out and refitted--hole gets bigger--its a one fix bolt --good old expansion types are way stronger +can be removed =refitted its a building not space rocket not a vehicle that has all sorts of other dynamic loads -no earth quakes -so good straight forward engineering is all that needed--that why i said just double up the number of thunder bolts --I understand the idea that being further away from way it could try to twist beams from walls --simple solution--pack ends of joist out sideways so there is no space for the beams to move from twisting off wall motion -, -
The POSIs Picnic: a solution is in sight.
scottishjohn replied to ToughButterCup's topic in General Construction Issues
suggested that 4 pages ago ..double up the thunder bolts+ screw wall plates together --job done - he would be doing the flooring by now--maybe even the carpets.LOL -
Gluelam connectors
scottishjohn replied to Russell griffiths's topic in General Self Build & DIY Discussion
not happy on that half lap joint --the pillar is not under the left hand side of the half lap --so that beam is all hanging on half its depth make the support post wider to support left hand side and it would be fine. you paid this engineer for this solution? -
Gluelam connectors
scottishjohn replied to Russell griffiths's topic in General Self Build & DIY Discussion
you got your posts ? If so sounds like a job for local blacksmith or garage to make you up a suitable "shoe" and get it galvanized or painted 5mm plate should the trick with bolts etc did your designer not spec something for this ? -
Concrete slump for icf
scottishjohn replied to Russell griffiths's topic in General Self Build & DIY Discussion
certainly poly types of ICF need it thicker than durisol or the hydraulic pressure is too great +that will cause lots of blow outs. even then different makers specify dif rates and types of mix --and very gentle pokering if any with poly types ,some say use self compacting concrete --but that will still have a slump rate. looking at the "velox " type which is basically durisol type stuff --but just flat boards and no webs,but lots of metal ties- and they pour as thick as poly types -just fully open void to fill ,no webs to go round and not a sign of bracing in any of the companies vids -but it is nailed together as well and looks like 3m pours after first 0.8m pour at slab certainly might consider that for basement /garage and a velox concrete roof to comply with fire regs for a garage below living space --just the stuff to make your bomb shelter out of . lol -
Concrete slump for icf
scottishjohn replied to Russell griffiths's topic in General Self Build & DIY Discussion
good question. I have been looking at all types of ICF and the different makers seem to specify different slump rates I will certainly be getting a slump tester of my own to check what they supply me before i let them start pouring and use my ICF suppliers spec as my guide -
https://www.septictank.co.uk/how-to-beat-the-2020-septic-tank-ban/ first thing is this true that 2020 could be a problem for those without a proper recorded of tank servicing. secondly ,if its red worms will they be the same as live in the bottom of my pond,which the fish dig for all the time? looks like a con --but maybe some mileage in dumping some from a pond in the septic tank
-
Stick build scaremongering or legitimate concerns?
scottishjohn replied to Ben100's topic in Timber Frame
who needs a nail gun if you can work like him -
you want low techthat will work one piece of wood which is long enough to sit over 2 joist at 600 cntre -make another piece which you nail to first piece -the lengthof which is correct to make the next joist 600mm centre from first one . make 2 of these and use them as spacing guides--it just drops over top of the joists and spaces them for you start at one end and get first joist square to walls or what ever you want it squre too --then just keep moving along. has to be square and correct spacing= floor sheeting will match up the second piece will be 60m less the width of your top runner on the joist first piece make it 700mm long -nail second piece inmiddle of it
-
If you think you are going to have to pay for new ones you could make up end sections to extend them ,if you wish solid wood that , has same profile but also has a tongue that goes right into first vertical web for extra fixing glue and screw it all in -- If you really worried make them up using good plywood layers to make solid end as glue lam end extensions - if still worried add extra long outer plywood braces both sides spread load further down the joists - cannot be that much load when you look at thickness of joists hangers--make the glumlam plywood pieces so they can be top hung if you like --no need for joist hangers then --not the simple job you wanted --but dam sight cheaper than new beams and probably stronger if you do it right
-
I now am working on my planning and one of things i noticed was the scottish water statement which says they only have to supply you water at 1bar - you could get more depending where you are --but 1 bar is minimum--so I am guessing I will need to fit pump etc as my plots are up a hill--time will tell something else to consider when buying a plot up a hill in countryside
