Jump to content

Advice on Planning Offer


Recommended Posts

Hi all,

 

I have a Bungaow with a field as part of the land. I say field, but we use it as a garden.

 

I got a local land planner to do a pre app for me, for a 1.5 storey building on the field, which came back from the council as No, basically. 
 

Mainly around the land being outside the settlement envelope, And classed as agricultural, current road too my bungalow not up to standard in terms of width and visibility splays etc, ecology concerns as we have a large pond with Great Crested Newts and they wanted Archeological trenching done aswell.

 

Needless to say, not a great start. All was quiet from this land planner, until last week, when he got in touch and said he had been mulling things over and wanted to make an offer of going for full PP on a success based fee.

 

So I would need to foot the bill for ecology and archeology surveys, then if he successfully got planning, I would need to pay £18k + VAT.

 

Ive already paid about £1800 for the pre app, ecology and archeology would cost me about £2.5k then his fee if he succeeds.

 

So I would end up spending circa £26.5k to get planning on the land, which seems way too high to me, and I’m not really prepared to spend that tbh.

 

Just wanted to get other people’s views as to whether this success fee is actually reasonable, or is it taking the pinkle.

 

The cynic in me is thinking he wouldn’t bother taking it on if there wasn’t a chance of him getting the PP.

 

Any advice welcomed

 

John

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you are only in for an extra £2.5k then you need to decide if it is worth it.  Perhaps a developer would be willing to take a punt? Some areas of land are best left as they are or everywhere will be built on.

 

For a single dwelling it may be quite expensive.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, Mr Punter said:

If you are only in for an extra £2.5k then you need to decide if it is worth it.  Perhaps a developer would be willing to take a punt? Some areas of land are best left as they are or everywhere will be built on.

 

For a single dwelling it may be quite expensive.

Fully get that POV. The field is basically a 1.3 acre garden as our current house is inset 1m into it. 
 

The Village envelope line literally comes down between the house and the field, which just seems odd, given it’s part of our plot.

 

My thoughts were the same that if doing multiple dwellings, then it’s probably reasonable, but for one it seems very expensive, as I had a friend get PP on some land for £10k all in ( appreciate all land is different and needs different approach in some cases)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, john0wingnut said:

New house.

Then that sounds a reasonable price to pay. Consider the uplift in value of the land if you can get PP for a house.

 

But I would want an absolute upper cap on his fee, not a completely open ended agreement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, ProDave said:

Then that sounds a reasonable price to pay. Consider the uplift in value of the land if you can get PP for a house.

 

But I would want an absolute upper cap on his fee, not a completely open ended agreement.


I would indeed get it in writing, but he has stated £18k + VAT due upon successful granting of PP.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In my experience, getting something just on the edge of a settlement can be a real pain, so a success based fee is probably a decent way to go - if you've got a quote for 12k already on a normal basis, then 18k on a bonus scheme doesn't seem unreasonable at all!

 

(I'm clearly working at the wrong end of the country with those planning fees!)

Edited by the_r_sole
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would any SPA/SANG or CIL contributions also apply to the new build dwelling, which will also start to increase those pre-construction costs?

 

Even though the fees may seem a lot, what percentage of the new build cost and/or re-sale cost would they be, probably quite minimal?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, DevilDamo said:

Would any SPA/SANG or CIL contributions also apply to the new build dwelling, which will also start to increase those pre-construction costs?

 

Even though the fees may seem a lot, what percentage of the new build cost and/or re-sale cost would they be, probably quite minimal?

 

CIL wise I would apply for exemption as doing self build, but Pre-App did not mention anything around SPA / SANG applying.

 

True - re the % of costs. if one worked off say £500k, £25k is only 5%.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, the_r_sole said:

In my experience, getting something just on the edge of a settlement can be a real pain, so a success based fee is probably a decent way to go - if you've got a quote for 12k already on a normal basis, then 18k on a bonus scheme doesn't seem unreasonable at all!

 

(I'm clearly working at the wrong end of the country with those planning fees!)

 

The thing I dont quite understand is, at land registry the land in question is part of the title register etc, thus part of the current house plot. So why does the settlement line bisect my current house from the land, when the current house sits 1m over that line?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, john0wingnut said:

 

The thing I dont quite understand is, at land registry the land in question is part of the title register etc, thus part of the current house plot. So why does the settlement line bisect my current house from the land, when the current house sits 1m over that line?

 

Land registry plans show your ownership, ownership boundaries aren't considered or referenced in local plans (unless you submit your boundary for consideration to be adopted into the local plan)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

+1

Settlement boundaries don't have to be precise to 1m.  The original boundary might have been a hand drawn line on a map that just got digitised incorrectly. 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I probably wasnt really clear. The land in question is actually used as our garden, all be it 1.3 arces.

 

So I suppose my thought process was, that being the garden of the property, it should be on the settlement side of things, along with the house.

 

Fully appreciate that if I were to buy the adjoining field, it would be outside, but, this is essentially our garden and they state its agricultural land and hence not included.

 

John

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, john0wingnut said:

 

CIL wise I would apply for exemption as doing self build, but Pre-App did not mention anything around SPA / SANG applying.

 

True - re the % of costs. if one worked off say £500k, £25k is only 5%.


Just remember to qualify for exemption normally means obtaining a self-build mortgage and the property cannot be sold within three years post completion. If you were thinking of selling, some of those design costs could be absorbed throughout the build and then re-sale costs meaning their impact would not be ‘as bad’.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...