An excerpt from the ERP guidelines update.
Quote ....
"
The modulation of oil-fired boilers
The major stumbling block is on the modulation of an oil-fired boiler. Generally speaking, certainly in the UK, a domestic oil-fired boiler typically has a fixed burner, a non-modulated burner.
It simply cycles on and off when it reaches its required temperature.
However in the current proposals, manufacturers would incur a penalty of 7% on the overall efficiency of the boiler.
We consider this notion to be very unfair as we don't see any great difference in efficiency between an on/ off burner and a modulating burner.
As a result we believe, a penalty which takes 7% off the efficiency of, for example, one of our oil-fired boiler will make it difficult, if not impossible, for oil-fired boiler to continue in the UK without changing to a modulating burner.
A modulating burner would cost almost double the price of the present burner used in oil burners and also require an increase in controls complexity.
All of which are relatively untried and tested so as a result we think it could signal the end of oil-fired boiler.
In what is generally a price-sensitive market, the price of an oil-fired boiler would increase significantly, thereby reducing accessibility and meaning homeowners would probably be forced to look for other means of heating their homes."
Delete his phone number. He clearly doesn't understand the problem. ( * )
There's no way you'll be able to run the Ufh direct via motorised valves and an UVC unless he proposed fitting a large, as in 300ltr, buffer tank.
It's not about efficiency, it's about being matched to the heat load properly.
Condensing is nothing to do with modulation, and it's modulation you'd need to lower the heat output to run the Ufh efficiently. As the boiler is basically on or off ( 100% of the heat capability or 0% of it ) then you need to use a TS or buffer to capture and hold the pulsed-in high grade heat so the Ufh can just gently draw what it needs and in the quantity it's needed.
The use of a TS also means you can set the boiler flow temp and the TS stat accordingly to dictate ( near as damnit ) the return temp. That means you can optimise the efficiency of the boiler by staying in the ideal flow - return temp range to promote full condensing operation.
( * ) In the boiler manufacturers installation instructions ( MI's ) it'll actually say that you need to 'design out' any scenario which would result in the boiler 'short-cycling', one which the UVC and direct fed Ufh would instantly create . A poorly designed system could see you with no warranty as short cycling an oil boiler will seriously affect it's longevity, plus it'll be using a lot more oil.