Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

BuildHub.org.uk

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Self build dream turning into unaffordable nightmare

Featured Replies

Ok. Long one this.

Have a house in the Thames Valley on lovely plot. However it is a disaster internally - think blow air heating, poor layout etc. Owned it since 1999.

In 2023 decided to enlist architects to remodel. Gave a budget of £750k. They said it would be tight, but went ahead. Came up with 3 great schemes, but cost £1.8m for our preferred one.

They had a pet builder who advised it probably could be built for £1.4m, but both he and the architects advised to demolish and rebuild as it saved VAT, eliminated unknowns and enabled a better design. The builder reckoned that could be done for £1.4m. That was Spring 2024.

So we embarked on that. Lovely design etc 330sq m with integral garage, 5 beds/baths, underfloor heating throughout, ASHP, solar, battery, polished concrete ground floor, top quality finishes.

Finally done and passed planning in September 2025. Design/build with pet builder £1.8m. Went out to tender with 2 builders architect recommended - £2m!

Value engineered. Cut back on some finishes. Pet builder now £1.7m as of August 2026.

Decided it was now or never. Planning conditions discharge ran over thanks to council. Still not fully discharged.

Had a phone call from the architect yesterday to say that builder now wants another £200k as we won't be starting until new year due to delays. (Was meant to be mid-October).

Architect is now suggesting re-tendering.

I have spent around £150k in fees with nothing to show for it.

I thought I was doing the right thing by engaging architects.

Where do I go from here? All my (AI) research says you should be able to build this to a really high spec including demolition for around £1.6m not including architect fees.

Can you sense check this please?

Edited by mrcerec
Remove duplicate sentence

330m² and £2M, that's £6k per m². That is super expensive maybe location carries a huge premium for labour or you have everything as the gold plated solution, or have you designed something really difficult and expensive to build?

Maybe some images of what you are planning may help?

2 hours ago, mrcerec said:

sense check this please?

First of all. You are doing exactly the right thing stepping back and having a big think. Don't be pressurised to carry on on their terms.

2 hours ago, mrcerec said:

Value engineered. Cut back on some finishes.

That's not value engineering. That's a reduction in scope or quality while builder and designers keep their margins.

Value engineering is using geometry and engineering to get efficient construction.

2 hours ago, mrcerec said:

builder now wants another £200k as we won't be starting until new year

Inflation is 3.6%. He just wants to milk the job, or is busy elsewhere. Seems rather cosy with the architect who hasn't questioned it.

Back to basics. Describe the house and the construction method.

What stage are you at?

Thames valley will be expensive but they all knew that. It's not as if you have relocated.

New starts are greatly reduced, so there are good workers looking for work, and soon may even consider reducing their expectations.

Although you sat you have 'value engineered' were you perhaps encouraged to include all these things at thd design stage? It's easy to be swept along with 'that would be nice' without being told the cost.

This is related - some friends of ours recently moved into their 'self-build' barn conversion. The contractors have been a nightmare - taking about 18 months longer than quoted, mainly by not having enough people on site.

The saving grace is that the architect had a QS written into the contract - stage payment was only made when the QS agreed that a task had been completed (or his view on the % completion of a task). There remains a haggle over the final bill - but my friends are going to win most of that - with the help of the QS.

Suggest (a) bear this in mind for later; (b) get a QS to cost the design up and use that as a basis for discussion with the architect and any builders (make the calcs transparent if you like)), (c) consider other ways of getting the project done - e.g. project manage yourself or hire someone yourself to project manage the trades, (d) get more quotes from people not associated with the architect.

This smells of 'pet builder with tight relationship with architect finds client with fat wallet and takes the, err, mickey'.

Edited by Alan Ambrose

  • Author

Thanks for replies so far. See below for an elevation and plans

Screenshot_20261118_140313_My Files.jpg

Screenshot_20261118_140259_My Files.jpg

Screenshot_20261118_140241_My Files.jpg

Looks a reasonable design to me. Yes, a bunch of glass and flat (or flat-ish) roofs, but still.

>>> I have spent around £150k in fees with nothing to show for it.

Well you have a design & planning permission - so you could probably recoup your cash if you want.

That's a lot though, I was probably <£10K at that stage, but I'm very DIY, including design & planning.

I think you need to do some work or employ someone to do the work for you. Shop the design to some more builders, get a QS to cost up, examine other ways of getting the project done.

Or you could just wave your wallet, but do keep tight control of the purse strings going forward and do your due diligence - as once they've smelled blood...

1 hour ago, Alan Ambrose said:

£150k in fees with

I'm sad to say that is common. If the build cost is £1M itx difficult to justify that.

1 hour ago, Alan Ambrose said:

Looks a reasonable design to me. Yes, a bunch of glass and flat (or flat-ish) roofs, but still.

A lot of corners and angles which does increase the cost and complexity. But on a >£1m build that shouldn't be a huge deal.

  • Author
9 minutes ago, Alan Ambrose said:

Looks a reasonable design to me. Yes, a bunch of glass and flat (or flat-ish) roofs, but still.

>>> I have spent around £150k in fees with nothing to show for it.

Well you have a design & planning permission - so you could probably recoup your cash if you want.

That's a lot though, I was probably <£10K at that stage, but I'm very DIY, including design & planning.

I think you need to do some work or employ someone to do the work for you. Shop the design to some more builders, get a QS to cost up, examine other ways of getting the project done.

Or you could just wave your wallet, but do keep tight control of the purse strings going forward and do your due diligence - as once they've smelled blood...

1 minute ago, -rick- said:

A lot of corners and angles which does increase the cost and complexity. But on a >£1m build that shouldn't be a huge deal.

Do you think there should be cheaper quotes out there?

  • Author
24 minutes ago, saveasteading said:

I'm sad to say that is common. If the build cost is £1M itx difficult to justify that.

Build cost is north of £1.5m atm. I'm looking for a sense check on this all

  • Author
3 hours ago, JohnMo said:

330m² and £2M, that's £6k per m². That is super expensive maybe location carries a huge premium for labour or you have everything as the gold plated solution, or have you designed something really difficult and expensive to build?

Maybe some images of what you are planning may help?

Images below. Interested to hear your thoughts thanks

Just now, mrcerec said:

Do you think there should be cheaper quotes out there?

I'm afraid you are asking the wrong person. I'm a keyboard jockey with dreams of a build. Not got as far as doing it yet. I can only talk in generalities based on my research (and reading pretty much everything on this site).

I know that cost increases in the building industry have been through the roof since 2020 so costs going up is not a surprise. But as far as the baseline cost goes it's too difficult to say from just the plans.

The basic structure should cost a lot less, but high end finishes and attention to detail can cost as much as you are willing to pay so whether the price is reasonable depends a lot more on the detailed spec.

Edited by -rick-

What is the place worth at the moment?

Having lived and worked in the Thames Valley (Marlow), and unless things have changed since I dropped out, there was a lot of willy waving about property prices. You can buy a 2 bed semi down here for £115.

You may find a staged renovation/extension a lot more cost effective. Seems to me that they are costing in £20k per tree in the images.

The VAT saving of 20% is gobbled up by the builder, and they are probably putting a premium on for the size, even though most of the increased volume is air.

3 minutes ago, SteamyTea said:

What is the place worth at the moment?

And also what's the estimated valuation when complete? Is that in line with similar local properties?

Self builds (especially main contractor lead ones) will often be more expensive than the end value of the property. It's not in itself a problem so long as you want to live there long term and the valuation isn't crazy different. But if it's crazy different then that a big red flag.

All of the suggestions so far are very helpful, even if the outcome doesn't change the answer much, you'll feel reassured.

Not wanting to be a negative voice but a cautionary tale.....some friends of friends had a not disimilar design (high spec, lots of glass, lots of angles, sloping site, gull wing roof, the whole 9 yards).

Their plot also had pp for a cluster of more 'traditional' constructed, but very nice detached houses at the bottom of the drive. Those houses were built and looked good, so when they had an acceptable quote from that builder they went ahead.

Who knows what happened then, was the design outwith the builders experience, was the contract written in such a way that was prohibitive to the quality that should have been delivered actually being delivered, was the project manager not up to the job? Who knows but the end point was litigation and circa 12 months out of the house for remedial works, not at their cost but.....

So whist the costs are clearly an important metric, they are only one and in some ways there are more places for "errors" to occur in a more complex building.

Having said all that people do and have here delivered fantastic projects by being "informed" and involved.

Wishing you every success

7 hours ago, mrcerec said:

Gave a budget of £750k. They said it would be tight, but went ahead. Came up with 3 great schemes, but cost £1.8m for our preferred one.

How much warning or expectation setting did they give you that they were working on designs likely to cost over twice your specified budget? That's a red flag for me! (Unless it was you pushing up the budget along the way?)

Roughly how does the £150K to get you this far break down? Do you have plans approved by building control? Have you demolished yet?

A cosy relationship between architect and builder doesn't have to mean anything underhand, but can result in them valuing their relationship over future projects above delivering the best value for you and I think you risk being in that position.

3 hours ago, Alan Ambrose said:

get a QS to cost up

I think this is good advice. It sounds like you've got enough detail of design and materials for a QS to cost the project pretty accurately - do that first and then put the project out to tender again, with the QS managing the tender process.

I would want to find a couple of builders for myself not just rely on your architect's list - recommendations from friends, looking around for similar local projects and knocking on the door to ask who built them.

You are definitely doing the right thing pausing for breath, don't get bounced into starting when the costs seem out of control and neither your builder nor your architect seems interested in reining them in.

I wrote a reply but can't see it now.

In summary Says 1.2M to 1.5 is about right for that in your area.

  • Author
9 minutes ago, saveasteading said:

I wrote a reply but can't see it now.

In summary Says 1.2M to 1.5 is about right for that in your area.

So being quoted nearer £1.9m for those plans with extremely high spec is over the top in your opinion?

  • Author
28 minutes ago, torre said:

How much warning or expectation setting did they give you that they were working on designs likely to cost over twice your specified budget? That's a red flag for me! (Unless it was you pushing up the budget along the way?)

Roughly how does the £150K to get you this far break down? Do you have plans approved by building control? Have you demolished yet?

A cosy relationship between architect and builder doesn't have to mean anything underhand, but can result in them valuing their relationship over future projects above delivering the best value for you and I think you risk being in that position.

I think this is good advice. It sounds like you've got enough detail of design and materials for a QS to cost the project pretty accurately - do that first and then put the project out to tender again, with the QS managing the tender process.

I would want to find a couple of builders for myself not just rely on your architect's list - recommendations from friends, looking around for similar local projects and knocking on the door to ask who built them.

You are definitely doing the right thing pausing for breath, don't get bounced into starting when the costs seem out of control and neither your builder nor your architect seems interested in reining them in.

Why the QS managing the tender process and not the architects.

The list of builders this time is 80% mine

>>> Why the QS managing the tender process and not the architects.

Because QS's focus on quantities & costs (the clue's in the name). They'll break your build down into tasks with m, m^2 & m^3 of materials; pricing for those, labour hours etc. Yes, big spreadsheets detailing everything you've ever heard of and then some more. Using industry standard numbers as the beginning and adjusting based on factors experience tells them are good. Ask your QS for the breakdown and you'll get a huge spreadsheet detailing every line item. If they get quotes from several builders they'll do a lot of work to ensure they're comparing apples with apples.

Architects usually are relying on the headline figure from a couple of builds they are familiar with. Great if they've just done something similar of a similar size recently, not otherwise. They may have not actually seen actual build costs, just some roundabout numbers. Ask your architect for the breakdown, i.e. how they reached that figure ... and their eyes will usually glaze over. If they get quotes from several builders they'll probably not do the work to ensure they're comparing apples with apples.

Edited by Alan Ambrose

The plans look good and I assume it is your dream house. Are you looking at doing anything yourself?

15% OHP is a high going rate and a shed load of money to a main contractor who may not even oversee the day-to-day running of the site on a project of this size.

Prelims and OHP can cost a fortune.

Once you have plans, spec and QS you should be able to shop around.

  • Author
6 minutes ago, Mr Punter said:

The plans look good and I assume it is your dream house. Are you looking at doing anything yourself?

15% OHP is a high going rate and a shed load of money to a main contractor who may not even oversee the day-to-day running of the site on a project of this size.

Prelims and OHP can cost a fortune.

Once you have plans, spec and QS you should be able to shop around.

Thanks!

Yes it's our dream retirement house. Not planning to do any ourselves.

What's a more normal OHP?

How do I choose a good QS and what should I expect to pay?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.