March 12, 20224 yr I know that it can report on how much energy im using, but how on earth does it know what I’m using that electricity on?!? Does my car (which I haven’t told them is EV!) take a different type of ‘lecy to my tumble dryer?!?
March 12, 20224 yr 3 minutes ago, CotswoldDoItUpper said: I know that it can report on how much energy im using, but how on earth does it know what I’m using that electricity on?!? Does my car (which I haven’t told them is EV!) take a different type of ‘lecy to my tumble dryer?!? Impressive
March 12, 20224 yr It doesn't. They literally make it up "based on properties with similar consumption profiles"
March 12, 20224 yr Author 8 minutes ago, markocosic said: It doesn't. They literally make it up "based on properties with similar consumption profiles" But how do they know I have an EV (actually 2!)?!? Edited March 12, 20224 yr by CotswoldDoItUpper
March 13, 20224 yr 51 minutes ago, CotswoldDoItUpper said: But how do they know I have an EV (actually 2!)?!? cos there is bugger all that will pull a consistently high current for the period it does to charge..!!
March 13, 20224 yr I assume your home idea of home entertainment is sitting around watching a 2 bar fire 🤣.
March 13, 20224 yr 3 hours ago, Iceverge said: I assume your home idea of home entertainment is sitting around watching a 2 bar fire 🤣. Mine is. And when it gets really cold, I turn it on.
March 13, 20224 yr Author 9 hours ago, PeterW said: cos there is bugger all that will pull a consistently high current for the period it does to charge..!! Even off the 3-pin granny charger?!?
March 13, 20224 yr It's a classic application of Machine Learning (AI). Supplier can 'train' an AI with the profile of typical appliances as every class of load has a particular usage pattern/wattage. These appear as deltas on the overal consumption so can be 'teased out' individually when enough readings over time are available. There's a branch of forensics that specialises in this kind of analysis so 'big brother' has a very sneaky way of keeping an eye on us through our 'smart meters'. Actually the first example I'm aware of dates back to the cold-war era East Germany where the Staatssicherheitsdienst used peoples electricity meters to infer behaviour.
March 14, 20224 yr 8 hours ago, Radian said: Actually the first example Was also used to find out where the terrorist were staying in Munich 1972. Edited March 14, 20224 yr by SteamyTea
March 14, 20224 yr On 12/03/2022 at 22:59, CotswoldDoItUpper said: I know that it can report on how much energy im using, but how on earth does it know what I’m using that electricity on?!? EDF no doubt promote this as a way of helping you understand your energy usage, and that could be beneficial to you. But you are clearly taken aback by the level of detail they appear to have about your household. Did they communicate with you in advance about the level of monitoring that would be performed and the way in which they would inform you about it?
March 14, 20224 yr 11 minutes ago, Radian said: which they would inform you about it? Here is my Mother's Smart Meter. Worse than a dumb one as it cannot be read at all.
March 14, 20224 yr Author 15 minutes ago, Radian said: EDF no doubt promote this as a way of helping you understand your energy usage, and that could be beneficial to you. But you are clearly taken aback by the level of detail they appear to have about your household. Did they communicate with you in advance about the level of monitoring that would be performed and the way in which they would inform you about it? I don’t mind at all, but it’s woefully inaccurate and just seems like complete guesswork about our appliances and when/how we use them! I don’t have strong feelings either way about smart meters in general, they’re not going to save me money, but they will educate about how much I use without having to do readings/calculations etc.
March 14, 20224 yr Fair enough. I think that what we really need is a more dynamic interaction between production and consumption so we can achieve a distributed network of microgenerators (i.e. resurrect the fits scheme such that it becomes more economically viable to have rooftop solar). Anything that detracts from the widespread adoption of the smart meters necessary for this is a concern to me.
March 14, 20224 yr Author This is true, it’s nearly cheeper for us to generate our own leccy from an LPG generator. Will be looking into PV too and none of this will show up on our smart meter!
March 14, 20224 yr Friend of mine got in touch yesterday to ask if I could replace her living room light, her new smart meter showed it costing over £2 per hour to run ….. 5x5w LED’s told her to keep the light and Chuck the display in the bin!
March 14, 20224 yr 40 minutes ago, markc said: 5x5w LED’s I have 1X3W. Just been chatting to my Mother's Carer, she said their monthly bill for electricity only (they have gas) is going up from £400/month to £800/month. There is 4 of them. She did not think that nearly £5k a year on just electricity was excessive. Pointed out that it was horrendously excessive. Edited March 14, 20224 yr by SteamyTea
March 14, 20224 yr 2 hours ago, SteamyTea said: I have 1X3W. Just been chatting to my Mother's Carer, she said their monthly bill for electricity only (they have gas) is going up from £400/month to £800/month. There is 4 of them. She did not think that nearly £5k a year on just electricity was excessive. Pointed out that it was horrendously excessive. How much? 🤪 an average of just over £100 per month covers my house and home workshop and I have a decent size lathe, milling machine, table saw, etc etc etc.
March 14, 20224 yr My theory is that your Smart Meter is telepathic. Or as has been suggested, guessing.
March 14, 20224 yr Author 3 hours ago, SteamyTea said: I have 1X3W. Just been chatting to my Mother's Carer, she said their monthly bill for electricity only (they have gas) is going up from £400/month to £800/month. There is 4 of them. She did not think that nearly £5k a year on just electricity was excessive. Pointed out that it was horrendously excessive. That’s absolutely crazy! Ours is going up from around £240 to around £320 with 2xEV and electric aga!! Heating by LPG and were on the price cap with no e7/e10 etc. Edited March 14, 20224 yr by CotswoldDoItUpper
Create an account or sign in to comment