scottishjohn
Members-
Posts
4259 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
21
Everything posted by scottishjohn
-
its where the self builder bit comes in I ceratinly have been doing it myself so far 0-but myage and old age problems preclude me from doing the whole job - -what percentage must be done by slef builder to class as such . first quote is going to be to get it water tight =except widows ,then maybe a second half to ginish it off ,with me doing bits in between to be able to claim the 5% back
-
Dry Ridge Question - opinions please
scottishjohn replied to w1zard's topic in Roofing, Tiling & Slating
why try to make concrete ridge tiles like a dry system the only reason for a dry system is to give ventilation to the roof space and I don,t see you achieving any great ventilation with what you have done I would cement them and get a much better fit and security from them moving over time if you want ventilation in the roof space fit some ventilator tiles looks crap to me but just my opinion -
Strip footings or insulated raft?
scottishjohn replied to Selfbuildnewbie's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
it was 20+ years ago my BL was involved and it failed for funding-no other reason-- -
anyone got a simple calcultor for working out a retaining wall
-
Strip footings or insulated raft?
scottishjohn replied to Selfbuildnewbie's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
netherlands is very low and most reclaimed land --so lots of wet ground at not to deep a depth and use brine loops for the bore holes -
Strip footings or insulated raft?
scottishjohn replied to Selfbuildnewbie's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
you only need to look at ground temps for uk at 1.5m and you will see that it will work bore holes are used mainly in areas where you have ground water leaking from the sea as wet ground transmission is at least twice as good as dry ground condtions , or no space for slinkies but most do not fit a large enough area of slinies due to space and cost maybe the SE has a problem due to the amount of wtaer that is extracted and lowering the water table?-so ground is dry I looked at that before I fitted ASHP to current house and the costs were prohibitive ,especially as they could not warranty how much heat they could get till they drilled the hole ,and then said we might need to drill another one -- solid rock is not good as the specicfic heat or any sort of rock is way below normal damp soil- unles your going dowmn to voer 100m . my brother in law was involved in a proposed project in cornwall to use a bore hole for geothermal heat to run a power station using old mining shafts as a a starting point It never happedned as they needed to get down 1km+ and then they would get superheated steam at over 300c+ back up the hole EST website --you got a link . If you had very boggy marshy ground around you or a lake or a river you can dump the GSP slinky into they work very very well in this country and willl outperform ASHP ,but cost is always going to alot more than ASHP and for the few days that the COP goes to 1-1 the ASHP will always be cheaper overall in uk -
Strip footings or insulated raft?
scottishjohn replied to Selfbuildnewbie's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
they do work very well if installation is correct Its just the cost to do it compated to air source makes them not as good an option in most situations but in cold climates they will out perfrom air source eveyr time -
Strip footings or insulated raft?
scottishjohn replied to Selfbuildnewbie's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
you could go halfway and insulate the strip founds same way and use B+B+screed so cold bridge gone anyway and anayway the sub soil temp in uk is about 12c all year round at about 1m deep or ground source heat pumps would not work --would they -
Strip footings or insulated raft?
scottishjohn replied to Selfbuildnewbie's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
I would like to see you quantify the real difference remeber that fully insulated foundation rafts to pour your floor and wall footing into come from countries with much harsher climates or even permo frost my average winter temp in s/w scpt;and is +3c not -15c or worse for months at a time likein northern european countries where these came from I doubt the extra 10K for the insualted raft will ever pay itself back just my view and full concrete raft floor will be more expensive than B+B hence why B+B they are used so much in uk they are cheaper to and if DIY it don,t get any easier and you have to option to correct any mistakes on drainge penetrations until you screed it I have no issues with the insulated raft system other than it seems OTT for this country -
Strip footings or insulated raft?
scottishjohn replied to Selfbuildnewbie's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
block and beam can be every bit as effective with UFH as you will put your insulation on top of the block+beam ,then add UFH,then screed it . It is something I am looking at seriously as i beleive block and beam will be cheaper to do and if self build a job you can do yourself you would sit your beams on the strip footings making them a bit wider to accomodate the beamsand add insulation at perimeter to isolate from walls -
look at this lifted from an article onundefloor heating and gas boilers Condensing boilers A condensing boiler is another excellent option for underfloor heating as they recover as much waste heat as they can. | They then reuse waste heat in the system, which would otherwise be put out into the atmosphere from the flue. Unfortunately, most standard radiators do not work as well with condensing boilers as they cannot make the most of the available energy. Traditional radiators have a flow temperature of 70°C and output of 60°C, which is above the range of a condensing boiler which operates at around 53°C. not 35c which was what someone was saying they were running thier boiler at
-
Strip footings or insulated raft?
scottishjohn replied to Selfbuildnewbie's topic in Insulated Concrete Formwork (ICF)
this post got me thinking I have always thought to just have a slab foundation /floor inside my old house for the UF as it would be cheaper BUT if would it be cheaper to block and beam it then maybe a good idea labour to fit the blocks and beams is a nearly a free bie to me and cost is paramount at this time I am working on a 300mm dig out below original floor level with some strip foundations for internal load bearing walls to support the upper floor joist Idon,t see any problem with ground loads as its very very solid all thoughts welcome i am just starting to clear out the inside and grading the stones into piles for small builders/arge builders and small rubble and the tons of old lime mortar -
I spoke to the iriash importer today abd after a long conversation it still seems thatTF is going to be cheaper basically the clay blocks with pearlite insulation is like and ICF build with out the wet concrete so yes for an old boy DIY then could be good but not for my job and the insulated blocks are not imported to UK at this time .although they were willing to get a price for them If I were keen but after the conversation seems not the right thing for me come in all sizes fro 100 -300mm and very long
-
"Iknow nothing -I.m from barcelona Mr faulty"
-
mineral wool --why not PIR foam surely
-
ao how do yhey bond to next layer and is it a viable cost comparison to going timber frame, as with my build I am building another house inside an old granitr building anbody got a link to them in uk
