Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

BuildHub.org.uk

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Joists 100mm short of a picnic. Trying to maintain my sense of humour....

Featured Replies

They have misread both dimensions, including the ones that they added...

 

I would go back with the actual dimension, the dimension between wall plates, and then the dimensions from the plans (both theirs and yours)

 

What it will show is what they have supplied doesn't actually meet any of these and they need to re-supply...

  • Replies 105
  • Views 18.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • I still say it’s the suppliers problem, why should you have to make more work because they cocked up?, simply tell them you want what you ordered, joists THAT FIT.

  • I was recently supplied incorrect grade of steel reinforcement mesh for my slab.   It was discovered by BCO during pre concrete inspection, after discussion with the SE the only sensible sol

Posted Images

Have you paid them?, if not just tell them you are not going to, as what they supplied is not what you ordered which makes them not fit for purpose . If you have paid them, tell them you either want them replaced with what you ordered or your money back and if that is not forthcoming you will take them to the small claims court. Simples.

5 minutes ago, PeterW said:

What it will show is what they have supplied doesn't actually meet any of these and they need to re-supply...

 

Yup. What they've supplied isn't consistent with any reasonable interpretation of the drawings (including the interpretation they've tried to squeeze past you).

The agreed drawings also say:

 

Wallplate.GIF.5fa8ff75a0a3d268be4fed04ee585ef9.GIF

 

Not exactly clear language, but is at least an admission that they were aware of the existence of wallplates.

  • Author
13 minutes ago, JamieL said:

[...]

as your diagram above is perfectly clear. You have told them that the width of the room is 3646 (in block 1 for example) and they have decided to provide joists that are 3560. Which is obviously going to be too short.

 

And they argue 3646 minus 2 lots of 50ml for the wall-plate is 3546. And that is the length of joist supplied. And each of those joists has a 50mm timmable end.

39 minutes ago, recoveringacademic said:

And they argue 3646 minus 2 lots of 50ml for the wall-plate is 3546. And that is the length of joist supplied. And each of those joists has a 50mm timmable end.

 

Why would they subtract the depth of the wallplate though? By definition, the joist ends have to rest on that! Ask them what they think the joists are supposed to rest on if not the wallplates.


The fact that they got it right the first time around shows that they've just cocked it up. Can you kick it above the head of whoever you're talking to and get a manager involved?

  • Author
11 minutes ago, jack said:

Why would they subtract the depth of the wallplate though? [...]

 

I asked that: 'Thats what we do because people get brassed off having to trim the ends....' And I replied: "but I asked you to provide trimmable ends and so that argument doesn't hold water really does it?"

12 minutes ago, jack said:

[...]

 Can you kick it above the head of whoever you're talking to and get a manager involved?

 

Yes, once I have exhausted things at this level.

 

It is really simple: should the 100mm (2 times 50mm wall-plates) be measured from the external datum - the wall, or the internal datum - the wall plates.

Last time the measure was from the wall. This time from the internal wall-plate. How was I to know that?

 

Here's the answer....

joists1.PNG.0ab427315bffbf6df09bcbf3f60f16ce.PNG

 

J001 on the schedule (RHS) shows the complete assembly (that includes the trimmable bits) as 3546. The walls are 3646 apart - deduct 100 for the 2 wall-plates and you get 3546.

 

I'm losing the will to live here.

  • Author
1 minute ago, the_r_sole said:

[...]

You are a self builder who seems to have given clear direction - the first time you got what you wanted and the second time, presumably with the same approach, you have ended up with joists which are too short - normal process doesn't come into it really.

[...]

 

Thats my point. The same approach and instruction resulted in two different outcomes.

 

 

Don’t pixx about with the monkey, go straight to the organ grinder. Demand the managers Email address and send him all the info with a demand to send the proper joists as ordered ASAP As this is holding up work on site (hint at wanting compensation).

Edited by joe90

Are these meant to be top hung - with the top chord resting on the wall plate?

  • Author
Just now, Mr Punter said:

Are these meant to be top hung - with the top chord resting on the wall plate?

 

No, they  are hanger-hung (to coin a phrase). Had they been top-chord hung, there'd be no argument. It'd have had to be 3646 + 100 (50 either side)

Wall plates can be anything from 38mm to 47mm, so why / how they deducted 100mm I am not sure.  With regard to trimming, with ICF you are unlikely to get the walls dead straight, so to ask for a 50mm trimmable allowance either end seems fairly sensible.  They messed up and will have to re-make.  They may be able to modify some of the longer ones - that is up to them - but they need to get a wiggle on or it will hold up your job. 

  • Author
10 minutes ago, Mr Punter said:

[...] but they need to get a wiggle on or it will hold up your job. 

 

Just a quick list for ya......

  • PP delay 6 months: permission given but ecologist forgot to tell me he had an email allowing us to start (another 2 months)
  • GCN license conditions 6 months delay
  • Contractor buggered off for 5 weeks without telling us: wall blew down 9 to 12 months delay
  • contractor buggered off multiple times at least a month at a time
  • steels contractor got the measurements wrong 2 months delay
  • architect - induced delay 1 month (all came down to the difference between max. and min. - copy and paste error on BR submission) 

Like I say at the beginning of this thread: Can't take a joke? Don't start.

11 minutes ago, recoveringacademic said:

 

Just a quick list for ya......

  •  PP delay 6 months: permission given but ecologist forgot to tell me he had an email allowing us to start (another 2 months) Communication
  •  GCN license conditions 6 months delay Bureaucracy
  • Contractor buggered off for 5 weeks without telling us: wall blew down 9 to 12 months delay Communication / A**ehole contractor
  • contractor buggered off multiple times at least a month at a time A**ehole contractor
  • steels contractor got the measurements wrong 2 months delay Measuring / Specification error
  • architect - induced delay 1 month (all came down to the difference between max. and min. - copy and paste error on BR submission)  Measuring / Specification error

 Like I say at the beginning of this thread: Can't take a joke? Don't start.

 

I think most on here will have had similar. I guess the current one with the joists is also "Measuring / Specification".

 

The "Big Boy" contractors do all they can to make sure they don't carry the cost of any errors - in fact may of them make much of their profit from what they consider extras / prolongation costs etc.  The poor self builder just has to take it on the chin it seems.

  • Author

The question this time round is:

 

In the light of the evidence presented, is it reasonable, yes or no, to argue the supplier should re-supply?

20 minutes ago, recoveringacademic said:

The question this time round is:

 

In the light of the evidence presented, is it reasonable, yes or no, to argue the supplier should re-supply?

 

Reading through everything I'd say that there is no doubt at all the the supplier has screwed up and should replace all the joists ASAP.

4 hours ago, recoveringacademic said:

To explain, I need to take you back to our flat roof joists ordered from the same company.  I ordered the flat roof joists based on the widest part of the  space to be covered. 1979mm. Those joists were also to be provided with trimmable ends. The joists arrived, I checked them and all is well. Each joist-end will need to be trimmed  a bit in some cases, more in others. The trimmable end allowance is 70mm each side. The wall-plate is 47mm each side. More than enough to allow the joist top chord to sit happily on the wall-plate

 

Ian is it the case that your previous order had the top chord designed on top of the wall plate and with this one it is designed to be flush with the face of the wall plate?  If this is the case it may account for the 100mm anomaly (although I am unsure who is at fault).

  • Author
29 minutes ago, JSHarris said:

 

Reading through everything I'd say that there is no doubt at all the the supplier has screwed up and should replace all the joists ASAP.

Thanks that's interesting. Encouraging. 

I'll try again tomorrow and see what happens. This game has a super steep learning curve doesn't it? 

 

Check the length of the other joists. Perhaps I'm wrong but it looks like they may have taken 100mm off the length of those even though some only have a wall plate one end? For example it looks like J003 goes from a wall to a beam? So they should be 2589mm less 50mm for one wall  plate = 2539mm. They have them as 2489mm ?

 

 

It sounds like some apprentice was told to allow 50mm for the ends to be trimmed and took that to mean trim 50mm off each end :-)

4 hours ago, joe90 said:

Don’t pixx about with the monkey, go straight to the organ grinder. Demand the managers Email address and send him all the info with a demand to send the proper joists as ordered ASAP As this is holding up work on site (hint at wanting compensation).

 

For every day this continues you are incurring consequential losses as a result of their error.

I would say to the supplier that you are willing absorb the losses of the first 3 days but after that they are liable. 

You have (hypothetically) labour on site unable to progress who still need paying.

 

 

 

3 minutes ago, willbish said:

 

For every day this continues you are incurring consequential losses as a result of their error.

I would say to the supplier that you are willing absorb the losses of the first 3 days but after that they are liable. 

You have (hypothetically) labour on site unable to progress who still need paying.

 

 

 

 

I’d be very surprised if their contract didn’t stipulate no liquidated damages or liabilities - not unusual tbh now and supply contacts are usually very tight on this sort of thing. 

I was recently supplied incorrect grade of steel reinforcement mesh for my slab.

 

It was discovered by BCO during pre concrete inspection, after discussion with the SE the only sensible solution was to take it up (two layers with UFH pipes tied to the top) and replace with correct grade.

 

After much back and forth with the supplier and some excellent advice from Citizens Advice, the correct mesh was delivered free of charge and £1k of credit put on my account for the consequential losses I suffered.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.