March 2, 20233 yr Please see attached. So this includes one structural survey, to find out what the walls are made of properly (ie : to find out what's best for the property) I've said I'm using the PassivHaus ethos but not necessarily going full PassivHaus given diminishing returns Is that quote fair? It seems quite a lot but I don't know if that's normal for PassivHaus
March 2, 20233 yr Basics are, there seems to be no real target values. Improve airtightness to what? Just a bit better or 1m3 per m2 at 50 Pa or better? Target U values, better than you find it is too vague. You need a clear statement of what you want to achieve, otherwise it's rubbish in rubbish out. As I mentioned in another thread linking an ASHP to PV and battery is daft. Let the PV and battery feed the house, if power is available the heat pump will use it.
March 2, 20233 yr Author 2 minutes ago, JohnMo said: Basics are, there seems to be no real target values. Improve airtightness to what? Just a bit better or 1m3 per m2 at 50 Pa or better? Target U values, better than you find it is too vague. You need a clear statement of what you want to achieve, otherwise it's rubbish in rubbish out. As I mentioned in another thread linking an ASHP to PV and battery is daft. Let the PV and battery feed the house, if power is available the heat pump will use it. Thanks If I get that detail, would the quote be fair?
March 2, 20233 yr The price seems fair, but does the architect actually have expertise on this stuff? A heating and ventilation company would probably be your best bet for the MVHR, ASHP and heating. I don't see the architect adding much there if at all. The architect should be able to do the other stuff and detail drawings will likely be necessary for some of it. But you could be paying a lot for simply a list that says new windows to x u-value, insulate floor with PIR etc.
March 2, 20233 yr Author 7 minutes ago, AliG said: The price seems fair, but does the architect actually have expertise on this stuff? A heating and ventilation company would probably be your best bet for the MVHR, ASHP and heating. I don't see the architect adding much there if at all. The architect should be able to do the other stuff and detail drawings will likely be necessary for some of it. But you could be paying a lot for simply a list that says new windows to x u-value, insulate floor with PIR etc. They've done PassivHaus stuff before which is why I went to them in the first place
March 3, 20233 yr Bit worrying they don't even know the correct term for passivhaus retro-fit, its Enerphit and has a complete spec and phpp sheet. Ask them to show you a completed one they have already done and visit a property they have converted.
March 3, 20233 yr I would get them to define what they mean by passivhaus ethos? Architects often specialise in asthetics, functionality, planning approval and the useability of a building. Not so much in the fabric quite often. If you are not too concerned with altering the house layout I would get a passivhaus consultant to do a PHPP of the building as is and also a suggested upgrade plan. Like Dave says enerphit is the natural target.
March 3, 20233 yr Author 6 hours ago, Iceverge said: I would get them to define what they mean by passivhaus ethos? Architects often specialise in asthetics, functionality, planning approval and the useability of a building. Not so much in the fabric quite often. If you are not too concerned with altering the house layout I would get a passivhaus consultant to do a PHPP of the building as is and also a suggested upgrade plan. Like Dave says enerphit is the natural target. Sorry PHPP?
March 3, 20233 yr On 02/03/2023 at 20:15, JohnMo said: As I mentioned in another thread linking an ASHP to PV and battery is daft. +1 On 02/03/2023 at 20:15, JohnMo said: Let the PV and battery feed the house, if power is available the heat pump will use it. and in between the ASHP cycles you can use a diverter and heat your water.
March 5, 20233 yr Author On 03/03/2023 at 12:44, Iceverge said: I would get them to define what they mean by passivhaus ethos? Architects often specialise in asthetics, functionality, planning approval and the useability of a building. Not so much in the fabric quite often. If you are not too concerned with altering the house layout I would get a passivhaus consultant to do a PHPP of the building as is and also a suggested upgrade plan. Like Dave says enerphit is the natural target. It was me who mentioned a PassivHaus ethos tbf. I said that PassivHaus has diminishing returns I contacted them after seeing this http://www.guytaylorassociates.co.uk/projects/passivhaus-manchester.html Also tbf I didn't speak to an actual architect. Edited March 5, 20233 yr by anonymous
March 8, 20233 yr On 05/03/2023 at 12:19, anonymous said: Also tbf I didn't speak to an actual architect. Who did you speak to and who drafted the quote?
March 10, 20233 yr Author On 08/03/2023 at 21:50, ETC said: Who did you speak to and who drafted the quote? Chris (director I believe?) I think an office administrator drafted the quote
March 10, 20233 yr 23 minutes ago, anonymous said: Chris (director I believe?) I think an office administrator drafted the quote Would have been a copy / cut / paste document tbh.
Create an account or sign in to comment