Trying to get planning for a site that has had an access for 100 years on to a 20mph Zone but each time I put planning in I get a different highways
consultant and they give a different site line measurement than the previous. Initially I argued with Highways because they based ther consultation on a 30mph road but they would not change argument.
So far...
16/07258/OT –Highways consultee stated;
‘Leeds Road is a secondary distributor road and sight lines of2.4m x 90m should be provided however if the applicant can demonstrate by a radar speed survey that vehicle speeds are contained at or below 30 mph 2.4m x 70m sightlines would be acceptable.’
during a telephone conversation with ************ after withdrawal of application he stated that he had erred in his consulation based on 30mph speed limit and stated that junction view lines would be achieved at 45m or less based on 20mph speed zone.
17/07322/OT – Highway consultee ************** based view line on 30mph, stating 15m to east and 70m to west
App/n4720.w/18/3207003 – planning inspector stated;
14. Notwithstanding the Council’s argument with regard to visibility splays, I observed on site that there would be a clear view to the east in excess of 100 metres for vehicular traffic and a greater view than stated for pedestrian traffic. In the opposite direction the curvature of the road, parked vehicles and existing vegetation close to the site entrance restricts the view from the track to the centre of the oncoming lane to 20 metres or so, without taking bonnet length into account.
The latest highways consultee states view lines as 20m each way.
Four different statements…
to make issues worse...
18/01707/FU –a recent decision on Station Road at Allerton Bywater which is also a secondary distributor road was allowed with view line distance of 30m although the road is 30mph. the highways consultee at no point has requested a speed check and as such distance should be 90m.
15/01177/FU- two house development on a type 1 road with 30mph speed limit. Both driveways are sloped back and view lines are impeded by 1200mm high boundary wall projections from neighbouring properties.
Inspection of the site reflects online plans which show one drive way having a view line to the left of 15m while the other driveway has a view line of 21m. At no point was a speed check or traffic analysis requested by highways.
Has anyone else suffered similar problems and how did you deal with it?