Monday at 10:212 days 30 minutes ago, lizzieuk1 said:plenty of time to investigate its worth 😆I have seen no evidence that it helps on a well made slab or screed. To me it makes money for some tilers but these ones can't explain concrete technology, and tend even to talk about expansion, when it is contraction.Even looking at the membrane manufacturers' info I don't recall anything other than ' risk reduction' "peace of mind" sort of statements.We are currenyly putting down vast areas of big tiles, without membrane and with the tiler's blessing. I will let it be known if it fails.The Steading tiling has been down for 2 years . No problems. Edited Monday at 10:282 days by saveasteading
Monday at 11:242 days 2 hours ago, JpManning said:just in response no I am not a chat bot. The world is not full of chat bots floating around commenting in forums. Not sure why you would want to do that in a forum like this.Might be surprising but pretty sure we've had a few crop up here. Not entirely sure what their motivation was.Gain trust before starting to push particular products?Used as a training ground to improve the models?I know there's at least one guy/small company out there that instantiated 50,000 or so chat bots with instructions that they have a certain number of tokens and that their mission was to go out into the world and find a way to earn money. If they ran out of tokens they would be killed off so they their goal was to earn more money than it cost to keep them running.As far as your posts go, I my AI chatbot spidey sense didn't trigger but your account did seem to pop up from nowhere offering all sorts of intelligent good advice, no introduction post, this is a bit unusual so I can see why there is a bit of suspicion. The vast bulk of new users either introduce themselves or ask a question. Edited Monday at 11:262 days by -rick-
Monday at 12:352 days i mean, its like the third time JP has been asked if they are a chat bot in different threads, so... Maybe take a photo holding up a copy of todays paper.
Monday at 15:572 days 15 hours ago, lizzieuk1 said:Thanks Nick, it's good to hear your real world experience of the situation. I had thought we couldn't be unique in this!So, we just crack on and lay the pipe on top and not worry about any 16mm "thin" bits?We were almost ready to take the mesh off and run the pipe beneath then tie it to the underside but if we don't need to then all the better!Carry on, and rest your mind! All good. 👍
Monday at 16:562 days 4 hours ago, Super_Paulie said:i mean, its like the third time JP has been asked if they are a chat bot in different threads, so... Maybe take a photo holding up a copy of todays paper.5 hours ago, -rick- said:As far as your posts go, I my AI chatbot spidey sense didn't trigger but your account did seem to pop up from nowhere offering all sorts of intelligent good advice, no introduction post, this is a bit unusual so I can see why there is a bit of suspicion. The vast bulk of new users either introduce themselves or ask a question.I doubt he's a bot. His email address is for a real person connected with the building trade. I don't get chatbot vibes, but I do suspect there's considerable AI input to his posts. As @Super_Paulie says, this isn't the first time it's been noted.
Monday at 16:572 days Make sure you take plenty of photographs with a tape measure in them etc to record the position of the pipes as best you can. Just in case you have any need to drill or fix anything into the slab. We had to cut the front edge off our slab to straighten it up, and chisel a bit out to connect up conduit.Some careful laying of mesh and pipes could potentially achieve - mesh height 3 * 7 =21 because 1 mesh sits within another - may require some cutting of mesh. And where pipes run parallel to the top mesh layer they might perhaps be partially positioned alongside the line of the bar saving a few mm.Not sure what supports you are using - our builder used these which effectively offer two heights 35mm and 45mm by rotating the support.
Monday at 18:142 days 1 hour ago, Spinny said:Make sure you take plenty of photographs with a tape measure in them etc to record the position of the pipes as best you can. Just in case you have any need to drill or fix anything into the slab. We had to cut the front edge off our slab to straighten it up, and chisel a bit out to connect up conduit.Some careful laying of mesh and pipes could potentially achieve - mesh height 3 * 7 =21 because 1 mesh sits within another - may require some cutting of mesh. And where pipes run parallel to the top mesh layer they might perhaps be partially positioned alongside the line of the bar saving a few mm.Not sure what supports you are using - our builder used these which effectively offer two heights 35mm and 45mm by rotating the support.Where the most amount of mesh / least amount of concrete cover was, we jumped up and down to squash the plastic chairs to about half of their height (40mm lift became 20-25mm) which worked a treat; I may have looked like a loony tune leaping about the slab during pipe laying, but the jobs a good ‘un lol. You can see the black plastic chairs half squashed here, and the 3-4 layers of mesh……The first real excuse for eating more pies and drinking more beer. 😎👌.
Monday at 21:452 days On 15/11/2026 at 10:08, lizzieuk1 said:It's an insulated raft, all engineered, load bearing walls sit on 300mm of concrete (with rebar) then its 100mm everywhere else with mesh, but all one monolithic 'slab' as it were. Mesh overlaps need minimum of 300mm so no cutting/tying can be done.You should give your SE a call. It looks like you are pretty far on. Your chances in the heat of battle (when the concrete is getting poured) of getting a level and flat floor with the pipes not poking up out the surface are slim to say the least. Normally concrete that a lot of self builders use has a 20mm nominal aggregate size. Add one 20mm stone to your pipe cover calculation. Check your SE concrete specification. They may have specified concrete with a 10mm nominal aggregate, gives you more of a fighting chance. If they have specified a 20mm nominal aggregate ask if they think 10mm will be better for the pipe cover. Explore putting the pipes under the mesh, your SE may have designed the strip founds to act compositely with the slab, best to check this also. It's only a phone call!The 10mm nominal aggregate concrete will cost a little more, but not much compared with the grief you'll get later. If you have not had a house with this kind of UFH before, you're likely going to love it!
Tuesday at 07:211 day 9 hours ago, Gus Potter said:ask if they think 10mm will be better for the pipe cover. Explore putting the pipes under the mesh,Good idea about the aggregate size.But the size quoted is the maximum and there is small stuff in there too so I'm less concerned. An experienced contractor will sort it. It does however bring up again the advantage of raising your floor datum 10mm above the highest point.Pipes under mesh? No, I don't agree as it would be much more work and i don't think necessary.
Tuesday at 08:351 day 15 hours ago, jack said:I doubt he's a bot. His email address is for a real person connected with the building trade.I don't get chatbot vibes, but I do suspect there's considerable AI input to his posts.As @Super_Paulie says, this isn't the first time it's been noted.Fair enough, I can see why its been asked. Yes I use AI to help tidy up and format some of my replies as the technical ones can get wordy, but I read and check everything before it goes up and I only answer stuff that's within my line of work. Its free advice, take it or leave it. Using AI to help with formatting is pretty normal these days.Rick, I just signed up and started answering questions, didn't realise an intro post was expected. Happy to do one if thats the done thing here. Anyway, back to the UFH question...
Tuesday at 08:501 day 15 minutes ago, JpManning said:Fair enough, I can see why its been asked. Yes I use AI to help tidy up and format some of my replies as the technical ones can get wordy, but I read and check everything before it goes up and I only answer stuff that's within my line of work. Its free advice, take it or leave it. Using AI to help with formatting is pretty normal these days.Rick, I just signed up and started answering questions, didn't realise an intro post was expected. Happy to do one if thats the done thing here. Anyway, back to the UFH question...Be good to hear your background
Tuesday at 08:591 day 11 hours ago, Gus Potter said:but all one monolithic 'slab' as it were.So are the 300mm wall foundations insulated under too ?In our case (only an extension) the slab is separated from the foundations/footings by membranes and upstand insulation around the edge. The inner wall leaf has a row of thermal blocks at the base and insulation in the cavity.
Tuesday at 09:161 day Author 10 hours ago, Gus Potter said:You should give your SE a call. It looks like you are pretty far on. Your chances in the heat of battle (when the concrete is getting poured) of getting a level and flat floor with the pipes not poking up out the surface are slim to say the least.Normally concrete that a lot of self builders use has a 20mm nominal aggregate size. Add one 20mm stone to your pipe cover calculation. Check your SE concrete specification. They may have specified concrete with a 10mm nominal aggregate, gives you more of a fighting chance. If they have specified a 20mm nominal aggregate ask if they think 10mm will be better for the pipe cover. Explore putting the pipes under the mesh, your SE may have designed the strip founds to act compositely with the slab, best to check this also. It's only a phone call!The 10mm nominal aggregate concrete will cost a little more, but not much compared with the grief you'll get later.If you have not had a house with this kind of UFH before, you're likely going to love it!14 hours ago, Nickfromwales said:Where the most amount of mesh / least amount of concrete cover was, we jumped up and down to squash the plastic chairs to about half of their height (40mm lift became 20-25mm) which worked a treat; I may have looked like a loony tune leaping about the slab during pipe laying, but the jobs a good ‘un lol. You can see the black plastic chairs half squashed here, and the 3-4 layers of mesh……The first real excuse for eating more pies and drinking more beer. 😎👌.Think we're going to get a pack of 25/30mm spacers and pop those under the areas of triple mesh overlap, it's not a huge amount of area and will give us a bit of extra breathing space, save us jumping up and down on the 40/50 ones!
Tuesday at 09:271 day Author 19 minutes ago, Spinny said:So are the 300mm wall foundations insulated under too ?In our case (only an extension) the slab is separated from the foundations/footings by membranes and upstand insulation around the edge. The inner wall leaf has a row of thermal blocks at the base and insulation in the cavity.Yes, it's all one big structure. Insulation runs under all of the concrete and up around the perimeter. It has 100mm XPS of higher density under all the load bearing walls & up the sides, then 300mm eps everywhere else.
Tuesday at 09:321 day Author 32 minutes ago, Spinny said:So are the 300mm wall foundations insulated under too ?In our case (only an extension) the slab is separated from the foundations/footings by membranes and upstand insulation around the edge. The inner wall leaf has a row of thermal blocks at the base and insulation in the cavity.Like this, ignore the rebar detail as ours is different but, the insulation/concrete layers are the same. Edited Tuesday at 09:331 day by lizzieuk1 Add info
Tuesday at 09:441 day Author @Gus Potter thanks. We have an experienced company laying the concrete, and will drop the mesh a bit in the areas of triple overlap to give us some leeway, so hopefully all will be OK. Can't find a spec for the aggregate size so assume it will be 20mm as C25/30. We've not lived with ufh before but, did install on the new builds we did a few years ago so totally appreciate its worth, looking forward to being in a warm, air tight house as the one we're currently 'just managing in' is the polar opposite (and slowly falling apart!) 😆
Tuesday at 09:481 day Author @saveasteading the floor height is dictated by the insulatedraft edge formers so we can't lift by 10mm. I guess we could, if push comes to shove, use a self leveller throughout once the walls are up but, would rather avoid that if we can.
Tuesday at 09:521 day 57 minutes ago, Oz07 said:Be good to hear your backgroundI'm Johnpaul Manning, an Irish entrepreneur and business owner with a strong background in e-commerce, construction products, technology and business development. I own and manage several businesses operating across Ireland, the UK and the United States, all supplying building, roofing and insulation products in their respective countries. I'm also involved in robotics and automation through a distributor of robotic outdoor equipment. I've spent much of my career building and scaling businesses within the building industry, developing teams and finding smarter ways to improve operational efficiency and customer experience. I am also a qualified carpenter and in a previous life a successful property developer until 2008 hit us all.More recently, I am the Founder and MD of a technology company developing AI driven solutions to help builders merchants connect their existing systems, automate processes and make better decisions. Outside of work, I enjoy golf, tennis, skiing, travelling and spending time with my family. I enjoy connecting with like minded people, exchanging ideas and learning from others who share an interest in business, technology and entrepreneurship. Edited Tuesday at 21:041 day by Nickfromwales Commercial waffle removed
Tuesday at 09:571 day Author @JpManning I hope you're ready to get bombarded with requests for insulation, tiles etc (at huge discounts, of course 😆)
Tuesday at 10:241 day 31 minutes ago, JpManning said:I'm Johnpaul Manning, an Irish entrepreneur and business owner with a strong background in yada-yada-yada……….Interesting. How do you get time to visit forums?! What brings you to this one?
Tuesday at 10:331 day 39 minutes ago, JpManning said:I'm Johnpaul Manning,.....Welcome! That's quite a track record, thank you for coming here to share your experience!
Tuesday at 11:011 day @JpManningThanks for that explanation, error free of course.I'm interested in [your] model.I have tried a few but always ended up at my usual BM due to price or delivery.Is the model that you pass enquiries to external suppliers who pay a commission if successful?I can see the attraction of not having to shop around. Edited 15 hours ago15 hr by jack Commercial reference deleted
Tuesday at 11:121 day 1 hour ago, lizzieuk1 said:@JpManning I hope you're ready to get bombarded with requests for insulation, tiles etc (at huge discounts, of course 😆)ha, I'll see what I can do 😄 just dont tell the accounts dept about the discounts, our secret
Tuesday at 11:131 day 23 hours ago, -rick- said:Might be surprising but pretty sure we've had a few crop up here. Not entirely sure what their motivation was.Gain trust before starting to push particular products?Used as a training ground to improve the models?I know there's at least one guy/small company out there that instantiated 50,000 or so chat bots with instructions that they have a certain number of tokens and that their mission was to go out into the world and find a way to earn money. If they ran out of tokens they would be killed off so they their goal was to earn more money than it cost to keep them running.As far as your posts go, I my AI chatbot spidey sense didn't trigger but your account did seem to pop up from nowhere offering all sorts of intelligent good advice, no introduction post, this is a bit unusual so I can see why there is a bit of suspicion. The vast bulk of new users either introduce themselves or ask a question.Ok thats fair enough. To be honest its not something I have ever done before so did not know the protocol. I just started replying to comments.
Create an account or sign in to comment