Its still BS. The only effective maintenance one can, once its clogged with silt, is to take it up and relay it including the base material. Which, quite obviously isnt going to happen. Even basic cleaning, almost no one is going to do
Just because someone produced a pretty graph, doesnt change reality out in the real world. I just look at what really happens, not what some desk jockey, paid by those pushing a product produces.
The principle of SUDS is sound, the application is mostly lip service, with products that clearly wont work long term. Proper solutions are expensive.
Permeable paving is essentially "delayed" hard surfacing.