7 hours ago7 hr 2 minutes ago, jack said:Doesn't COP take into account spin-up costs?The heatpump doesn't know whether the heat it's generating is going into pipework or the tank. Also, it's going to be an average over a period of time (depending how measured).So the average over the DHW run might be 3-4. But the COP for the stage when topping off the tank might be much lower and that might be where the bulk of energy goes into the tank (the initial warm up being efficient but lost) and the last, low COP, heat being left in the pipework and also lost to the tank (might get distributed somewhat to the CH system).Depends on the situation. If heating a tank from cold then the average should roughly reflect the actual heat into the tank. But if each run of the DHW you are heating the tank from 45 to 50, then you could spend a lot of high COP heating the loop to 45 (wasted) and then much lower COP going from 45 to 50 and then leaving 50C water in the pipes that doesn't go to the tank.
6 hours ago6 hr 37 minutes ago, -rick- said:The heatpump doesn't know whether the heat it's generating is going into pipework or the tank. Also, it's going to be an average over a period of time (depending how measured).I get the principles, I'd just like to understand how the numbers end up so bad that an immersion uses exactly the same amount of energy as an ASHP to provide the same amount of useful hot water.It would probably require calculating the volume of water in the loops and ASHP outside, the amount lost to ambient from that volume once the cycle is finished, the total energy provided by the ASHP during each cycle, and the amount of energy that makes it into the DHW tank. You'd also need to do that for different scenarios, such as topping up an already warm tank versus heating from cold, and at different outside temperatures.My gut tells me that unless there's a huge exterior volume and the tank is generally being topped up with very small amounts of energy rather than heated from a relatively low state of charge, a COP of ~4 should be more than enough to overcome the startup loss.To be fair, my gut has also shown repeatedly that it shouldn't be trusted.[Edited to add:] You also can't just allocate the low COP part at the end of cycle to the water left in the loop. It was heated from cold at a higher COP at the start of the cycle. I suspect it's best to use average COP for the whole cycle and work out how much you lose from the water in the loop after the cycle finishes.
4 hours ago4 hr 2 hours ago, Oz07 said:Would you have near a bedroom or not? I suppose could acoustically insulate more than elsewhereWe have an 8.5 kW Ecodan in use for 7 years now, sited against the house outside a spare bedroom / bathroom on the ground floor. Timber frame, walls 420mm, triple glazed etc. Being a light weight structure you are aware of a low frequency hum when on full tilt perhaps compared to brick and block build.You cannot hear the actual fan noise. We have nothing in front of the ASHP for 150 metres, so zero reflected sound which I think should be a consideration if possible.Personally I want it as close to the UVC as possible but that's a topic currently ongoing elsewhere.Recent figures for the last 12 months show our SCOP for DHW and heating is 4.07 from the FTC5 and 4.42 from a Shelly meter.
4 hours ago4 hr I think my description has become over simplified about why I chose immersion over ASHP.With a long pipe run I am using on average 0.3kWh of electric just reheating the water in the pipes etc (from ambient to around 55-60 degs). You also take a small hit in efficiency transferring heat via the coil and pumping, about 0.1kWh per heating cycle. So as an estimate using 0.4kWh of the 1.5kWh of electric used in each heating cycle doing nothing much. We ended up heating twice per day to get the outlet temp of the cylinder consistent during the day. So was using close to 3kWh, one heat cycle that was really needed the other maybe not, but it still consumed electric.With immersion we hold the cylinder at a higher temp (57 deg) and the water temperature doesn't vary by any noticeable amount during the day at the taps. Even with 2x heating cycles still programmed it only really does one good heat, taking about an hour with a small top up at night ready for a shower first thing if needed.We currently use about 4kWh (sometimes higher) on immersion, we used 3kWh or slightly under with ASAP. So immersion costing me 13p (Cosy rate) more per day or there about. But not having to run ASHP during a cheap periods to do hot water allows heating to run without interruption doing heating, which allows more storage of heat in the floor. So for example, currently putting 5kW of heat in to floor at a CoP of 5.5 is way better use of the heat pump, this afternoon it will run balls out for 3 hrs and stuff close to 15kWh of heat in to the floor. If I was also using it for DHW, I would be doing 1 hour heating water and 2 hours heating floor and only adding 10kWh of heat to house, that additional hour coming from the battery.More referring to my case and the costs of immersion v ASHP for heating DHW.
3 hours ago3 hr 1 hour ago, JohnMo said:I think my description has become over simplified about why I chose immersion over ASHP.Yes, thanks. I think your post does highlight how what works for you might not work so well for others and it's worth pointing that out when you suggest copying your solution.For example, you can benefit from running the ASHP flat out in heating mode during the cheap times. People with pipes in thin screed, overlay systems, fancoils or radiators might not be able to benefit like that. This shifts the balance further towards using the heatpump for DHW. Same, if they use a lot of hot water and need a big refill during the day (can argue that they should have a bigger HW tank but that can be a trade off).1 hour ago, JohnMo said:With a long pipe run I am using on average 0.3kWh of electric just reheating the water in the pipes etc (from ambient to around 55-60 degs). You also take a small hit in efficiency transferring heat via the coil and pumping, about 0.1kWh per heating cycle. So as an estimate using 0.4kWh of the 1.5kWh of electric used in each heating cycle doing nothing much.Each cycle was 1.5kwh? Not like 2kwh for the big reheat and 1kwh for the smaller one? Second case aligns more with your description of the situation and does highlight how lossy that second heat might have been. I know it's too late now but a couple of interesting experiments would have been:Use ASHP for big reheat but use immersion for the top upAlter pipework to keep the pipework leg to the HW tank primed with warm water when the CH side was running, reducing the deltaT when the DHW cycle starts and hence DHW startup costs. (extra heat in those pipes wouldnt be wasted as would find it's way to heat the fabric)
2 hours ago2 hr Just had a look back to 2 Nov 2025 (random day) did 2x heating cycles. The one starting midnight the other in the afternoon. So in this cases, 2.36kWh and 1.97kWh. Quite where 16kWh of actual hot water was, the equivalent of heating the whole volume from 14 degs to 47 degs twice. And now an immersion does the same hot water in a fraction of that.
2 hours ago2 hr 11 minutes ago, JohnMo said:Quite where 16kWh of actual hot water was, the equivalent of heating the whole volume from 14 degs to 47 degs twice. And now an immersion does the same hot water in a fraction of that.The obvious answer is that that amount of hot water didn't exist and there was an issue with the reporting.Assuming the energy in measurements are right (suspect) you were getting a COP of more like 1 so no wonder you see an immersion as similar. Reported performance from others is significantly better so I tend to think you are a more exceptional case than the norm.
2 hours ago2 hr Author 22 hours ago, Spinny said:MO tradespeople have been known to favour whatever implementation is simplest and the least work for themselves.I think this is the crux of the matter.On a more strategic level that's probably why the building industry is so risk averse/behind the times in general.
2 hours ago2 hr Author 23 hours ago, JohnMo said:heat via immersionThis is something that has been on my mind - considering we're also expecting to have solar and batteries.@-rick- mentioned this wouldn't pass MCS - true/false? Reasons?
1 hour ago1 hr 20 minutes ago, Bancroft said:@-rick- mentioned this wouldn't pass MCS - true/false? ReasonsTrue as you need to heat house and DHW via ASHP
1 hour ago1 hr 3 hours ago, Nestor said:We have an 8.5 kW Ecodan in use for 7 years now, sited against the house outside a spare bedroom / bathroom on the ground floor.Timber frame, walls 420mm, triple glazed etc.Being a light weight structure you are aware of a low frequency hum when on full tilt perhaps compared to brick and block build.You cannot hear the actual fan noise.We have nothing in front of the ASHP for 150 metres, so zero reflected sound which I think should be a consideration if possible.Personally I want it as close to the UVC as possible but that's a topic currently ongoing elsewhere.Recent figures for the last 12 months show our SCOP for DHW and heating is 4.07 from the FTC5 and 4.42 from a Shelly meter.I was referring to the cylinder
1 hour ago1 hr 3 hours ago, JohnMo said:I think my description has become over simplified about why I chose immersion over ASHP.The additional context is interesting, but I'm less interested in why immersion is a better solution for your specific situation (specific tariffs, etc) than I am in your suggestion that replacing an ASHP with an immersion heaterfor DHW is a "simple" solution that consumes no more power for the same amount of hot water.With the ASHP, you generated ~16 kWh in thermal energy on the typical day you quote above, for a total electrical input of ~4.3 kWh. You had 0.3 kWh in pipe losses, but that's thermal energy, so comes off the 16 kWh, not the 4.3 kWh. Assuming the pump is internal to ASHP, then it isn't an extra loss, it's part of the 4.3 kWh.If all that's correct, then ~4.3 kWh added ~15.7 kWh net to the thermal energy of the water in the DHW tank on the example day above.You say you now get by with about 4 kWh (or higher) on immersion alone, with the same hot water usage. How do you account for in excess of 11 kWh more thermal energy going into the tank when you heated it with the ASHP?I'm happy to be corrected on any of the above, but unless I'm missing something, I think @-rick- is right about something being off with the data.
Just now1 min Environment comes into it as well as the need to heat the building concurrently with the DHW.In our particular situation (we sit in a dip so cool and localised humidity) using the immersion to heat the DHW at around getting-up time means that the ASHP isn't getting hung up on higher temperatures and more frequent defrosts, just at the time the floors need charged with lower-temperature water...
Create an account or sign in to comment