Sunday at 09:013 days Morning,We are finally installing our A193 mesh into the raft foundation. I'm a bit worried about concrete cover though. Originally the plan was to tie the ufh to the top of the mesh but, now we've come to laying the mesh, I'm concerned we don't have enough tolerance for adequate cover. The mesh is on 40mm supports above insulation, mesh is A193 so 7mm but obv 2 bar thickness so 14mm, then we have some overlaps so, in places, that's 28mm. Pipes will be 16mm on top of that. If I'm adding correctly that means 40+14+16= 70mm over majority but 40+28+16 = 84mm! in places. Which in a 100mm slab leaves min 30mm cover to top of pipes over majority but (yikes) 16mm in the overlaps. Surely that's not enough and we have zero tolerance for any variations! Thinking we now need to put pipes directly on the insulation, which is a pita as we've placed half the mesh, have our dpm atop the insulation and the weather not great for sticking ufh pipe clips down to plastic sheet!😖😫
Sunday at 09:393 days Are your pouring a foundation raft or a floor slab. If it is the former, then 100mm of concrete sounds very small. For comparison ours was 250mm, and even the garage has 150mm.If it is a floor slab , then you might be able to consider removing some of the overlap and "tying" the mesh together with pieces of rebar. This is non-professional advice and should be checked.
Sunday at 10:083 days Author 24 minutes ago, BotusBuild said:Are your pouring a foundation raft or a floor slab. If it is the former, then 100mm of concrete sounds very small. For comparison ours was 250mm, and even the garage has 150mm.If it is a floor slab , then you might be able to consider removing some of the overlap and "tying" the mesh together with pieces of rebar. This is non-professional advice and should be checked.It's an insulated raft, all engineered, load bearing walls sit on 300mm of concrete (with rebar) then its 100mm everywhere else with mesh, but all one monolithic 'slab' as it were. Mesh overlaps need minimum of 300mm so no cutting/tying can be done. It's the concrete cover above the ufh pipes I'm concerned about though.
Sunday at 10:193 days Your maths is right, and 16mm over the laps isn't enough. Even 30mm is tight once you allow for the tamp and any high spots, and pipes that close to the surface can show up as crazing lines in the slab later.The easy fix, without lifting the mesh you've already placed, is to run the pipe under the mesh rather than on top. With the mesh on 40mm chairs there's room to feed 16mm pipe underneath and cable tie it up to the underside of the bars every 500mm or so, so it sits snug against the mesh. No clips through the DPM and nothing to stick down in the wet. That puts the top of the pipe roughly 60mm below the finished surface everywhere, laps included.A few other things worth doing:Ask your engineer to confirm they're happy with pipe directly under the mesh, as it's their raft design, but it's a very common detail.Pressure test the loops before the pour and keep them under pressure during it, so any nick shows up straight away.Sleeve the pipes where they come up at the slab edge and through any joints.Have someone walking the pour watching for loops being dragged or lifting.Sitting a bit lower in the slab just means a slightly slower response, which doesn't matter with a heat pump running low and steady.
Sunday at 10:283 days Author 6 minutes ago, JpManning said:Your maths is right, and 16mm over the laps isn't enough. Even 30mm is tight once you allow for the tamp and any high spots, and pipes that close to the surface can show up as crazing lines in the slab later.The easy fix, without lifting the mesh you've already placed, is to run the pipe under the mesh rather than on top. With the mesh on 40mm chairs there's room to feed 16mm pipe underneath and cable tie it up to the underside of the bars every 500mm or so, so it sits snug against the mesh. No clips through the DPM and nothing to stick down in the wet. That puts the top of the pipe roughly 60mm below the finished surface everywhere, laps included.A few other things worth doing:Ask your engineer to confirm they're happy with pipe directly under the mesh, as it's their raft design, but it's a very common detail.Pressure test the loops before the pour and keep them under pressure during it, so any nick shows up straight away.Sleeve the pipes where they come up at the slab edge and through any joints.Have someone walking the pour watching for loops being dragged or lifting.Sitting a bit lower in the slab just means a slightly slower response, which doesn't matter with a heat pump running low and steady.Thanks, I hadn't thought of tying it below the mesh but, not sure how easy that is in practice 🤔 or whether its easier to lift the mesh and start again. Thinking we could glue down pipe rails with the waterproof sealant stuff but, not sure if that's easier than tying pipes below the mesh.....
Sunday at 11:553 days 1 hour ago, lizzieuk1 said:how easy that is in practiceIt won't be easy. UFH is not conducive to easy manipulation unfortunately.Will you be able to, or have you planned for a screed layer? If so, you could lay pipe as you plan, on top, diverting round the 4 overlap areas to keep them at the 30mm below surface, then a shallow screed layer to increase that depth. Not sure what minimum depth of screed is possible.A screed layer also provides the opportunity to correct any concrete level issues that might occur.
Sunday at 13:113 days We had this exact issue on our slab under the basement. I considered attaching below the rebar but worked out it would’ve been a massive pain. We had the ceiling height to opt for a screed on top instead and so put 25mm PIR on top of the slab and fixed the ufh pipes to that and then 50mm liquid screed on top. We also did the same on the ground floor above the block and beam and slab where there was no basement underneath.Blog post here and there’s a thread of mine about attaching to the rebar somewhere on here too.
Sunday at 13:133 days 4 hours ago, lizzieuk1 said:Morning,We are finally installing our A193 mesh into the raft foundation. I'm a bit worried about concrete cover though.Originally the plan was to tie the ufh to the top of the mesh but, now we've come to laying the mesh, I'm concerned we don't have enough tolerance for adequate cover.The mesh is on 40mm supports above insulation, mesh is A193 so 7mm but obv 2 bar thickness so 14mm, then we have some overlaps so, in places, that's 28mm. Pipes will be 16mm on top of that.If I'm adding correctly that means 40+14+16= 70mm over majority but 40+28+16 = 84mm! in places.Which in a 100mm slab leaves min 30mm cover to top of pipes over majority but (yikes) 16mm in the overlaps.Surely that's not enough and we have zero tolerance for any variations!Thinking we now need to put pipes directly on the insulation, which is a pita as we've placed half the mesh, have our dpm atop the insulation and the weather not great for sticking ufh pipe clips down to plastic sheet!😖😫There’s zero issue here, same on loads of jobs I’ve been on / installed UFH / down to sporadic locations with, as you say, as little as 16mm concrete cover. These slabs are so ridiculously over-engineered you have nothing to worry about. This isn’t theory, these are on live projects where I am present from concept and design, site prep (inc demolition), foundation, superstructures, and some all the way to interior fit & finish.Tiled floors over 150m2, L-shaped slabs, changes in levels, you name it I’ve done it.I don’t even entertain expansion joints at thresholds (unless it’s a floating, thin screed) and I’ve been walking on these laid finished for 12-24 months after we’ve laid them (so I am answerable and responsible for any event of them failing).Stop panicking, it’s just another slab and life will go on. Remember that you’ll likely be self levelling over this also, adding further cover, reducing any ‘concern’; you need not be concerned 😉.
Sunday at 13:163 days 2 hours ago, JpManning said:Even 30mm is tight once you allow for the tamp and any high spots, and pipes that close to the surface can show up as crazing lines in the slab later.Do you mean hairline cracking? As this will occur in slabs without UFH pipes in them and 50mm cover over the mesh.
Sunday at 13:443 days 4 hours ago, lizzieuk1 said:Surely that's not enoughIt's plenty. Has someone told you otherwise? It doesn't really need any cover but it's tidier and safer covered. And best to specify something like 30mm rather than be random.Every slab, bridge, nuclear power station in the world has hairline cracking and your mesh is there precisely to keep it hairline.There's lots of nonsense written about expansion joints. Concrete contracts and cracks a bit when curing, then stays there.As I often say... do not let anyone add water to the mix. That's what makes it crack too much. Tell the delivery driver that nobody can instruct it. It's a shame for the contractor if they need more effort, but that's how it is.
Sunday at 14:243 days Fair question, lizzieuk1. With half the mesh already down, tying under it is fiddly rather than hard: lift the sheet edge a little, feed the pipe through and tie it up as you go. If it turns into a fight, the others are right that 30mm cover over most of the slab is fine, so you could simply divert the pipe around the laps, or only tie it under the mesh where the sheets overlap and leave the rest on top. I'd skip gluing rails to the DPM in this weather, as they tend to come loose once people start walking the pour.Nick, yes, I meant hairline cracking that can follow a pipe line where the cover is very thin. As you and saveasteading say, a slab will hairline crack anyway and the mesh keeps it that way, so it's cosmetic rather than structural, and any levelling compound on top covers it.
Sunday at 14:363 days 12 minutes ago, JpManning said:lift the sheet edge a little, feed the pipe through and tie it up as you go.Please tell me it’s April 1st?!
Sunday at 15:373 days 57 minutes ago, Nickfromwales said:Please tell me it’s April 1st?!I suspect @JpManning as chat bot. Feeding pipe loops under mesh sheets would not be possible.
Sunday at 23:593 days Author 10 hours ago, Nickfromwales said:There’s zero issue here, same on loads of jobs I’ve been on / installed UFH / down to sporadic locations with, as you say, as little as 16mm concrete cover.These slabs are so ridiculously over-engineered you have nothing to worry about. This isn’t theory, these are on live projects where I am present from concept and design, site prep (inc demolition), foundation, superstructures, and some all the way to interior fit & finish.Tiled floors over 150m2, L-shaped slabs, changes in levels, you name it I’ve done it.I don’t even entertain expansion joints at thresholds (unless it’s a floating, thin screed) and I’ve been walking on these laid finished for 12-24 months after we’ve laid them (so I am answerable and responsible for any event of them failing).Stop panicking, it’s just another slab and life will go on. Remember that you’ll likely be self levelling over this also, adding further cover, reducing any ‘concern’; you need not be concerned 😉.Thanks Nick, it's good to hear your real world experience of the situation. I had thought we couldn't be unique in this! So, we just crack on and lay the pipe on top and not worry about any 16mm "thin" bits? We were almost ready to take the mesh off and run the pipe beneath then tie it to the underside but if we don't need to then all the better!
Monday at 08:232 days 8 hours ago, lizzieuk1 said:real worldThe pipe is horrible to handle in the best of circumstances. It comes in a long coil , doesn't want to straighten and must be laid and fixed as you go. There is no way you could fiddle it under the mesh.Have a few heavy jumps on any high spots.When it comes to screeding, point out any spot that is really high. You could ask them to use that as their datum.What you must not have is an exposed pipe which then gets ground off for a smooth finish.Plan ahead and you will be fine, and be in control of the screeder.16 hours ago, Mr Punter said:suspect @JpManning as chat botThere's a rare honour and challenge. Give us a reply that shows you are not.
Monday at 08:542 days 19 hours ago, Nickfromwales said:Do you mean hairline cracking? As this will occur in slabs without UFH pipes in them and 50mm cover over the mesh.Yes hairline cracking. Also if the floor is being left unfinished with flooring which would not be overly uncommon you will see the lines of the piped under the concrete.
Monday at 09:062 days 17 hours ago, Mr Punter said:I suspect @JpManning as chat bot. Feeding pipe loops under mesh sheets would not be possible.Hi Punter just in response no I am not a chat bot. The world is not full of chat bots floating around commenting in forums. Not sure why you would want to do that in a forum like this.Reason for my thinking of putting the pipes under the mesh is The installer never indicated the size of the floor so as long as its not a big area clipping the pipes to the underside of the mesh is a viable option (obviously not if its a big floor area)As there is already space under the mesh to utilise then try use it rather than risking cracking in the floor later by forcing a solution that could fail. Adequate cover of pipes is important as the concrete floor will act as a radiator and if the pipes are too close to the surface not only will you get excessive cracking but also the real purpose of the UHF system is its ability to radiate heat from the concrete. The less concrete on top of your UFH pipes means your concrete will hold less heat and radiate less when the heating is turned off.Also as a point to note this is something I have had to do in the past due to restrictions in levels. It does work.The only other alternative would be to lift all the mesh and start from the beginning with your UFH piping.
Monday at 09:222 days Both @Nickfromwales and @saveasteading offer the best advice. @JpManning not a bot though very neatly written and worded.What is your final floor finish above the slab?
Monday at 09:312 days If it’s the initial pour of a raft foundation, can you not just put extra concrete to give more cover and lift the levels of everything by say 10mm? i.e. start with a new datum level.Are the planning restrictions so tight to prevent this ?Seems such an obvious solution I must be missing something.On our build there were strict limits on ridge height but fortunately no outside ground level datum, so we just lifted the outside ground level . Edited Monday at 09:332 days by FarmerN
Monday at 09:392 days 5 minutes ago, FarmerN said:Seems such an obvious solution Good point. I had rather assumed that the structure was in place. Door frames would be the likeliest constraint. But a few mm extra is unlikely to matter.
Monday at 09:392 days Author 16 minutes ago, JpManning said:Hi Punter just in response no I am not a chat bot. The world is not full of chat bots floating around commenting in forums. Not sure why you would want to do that in a forum like this.Reason for my thinking of putting the pipes under the mesh isThe installer never indicated the size of the floor so as long as its not a big area clipping the pipes to the underside of the mesh is a viable option (obviously not if its a big floor area)As there is already space under the mesh to utilise then try use it rather than risking cracking in the floor later by forcing a solution that could fail. Adequate cover of pipes is important as the concrete floor will act as a radiator and if the pipes are too close to the surface not only will you get excessive cracking but also the real purpose of the UHF system is its ability to radiate heat from the concrete. The less concrete on top of your UFH pipes means your concrete will hold less heat and radiate less when the heating is turned off.Also as a point to note this is something I have had to do in the past due to restrictions in levels. It does work.The only other alternative would be to lift all the mesh and start from the beginning with your UFH pipi6 minutes ago, Nestor said:Both @Nickfromwales and @saveasteading offer the best advice. @JpManning not a bot though very neatly written and worded.What is your final floor finish above the slab?Yes, agreed. Having been on the forum a while I know there is a lot of valuable experience on here so very grateful for that. There will be hard flooring on top (porcelain or ceramic) so no worry about aesthetics of hairline cracks and that will obviously add extra cover, just need to ensure the tiles are protected so likely need decoupling matting, happy to take opinions on that too!So long as the integrity/functionality of the raft or ufh aren't compromised then we're very happy to carry on with pipes on top of the mesh. Having roped the teenager and his friends in to help us lay it, as its bloody heavy/cumbersome with 2 of us, very glad not to have to move it again! Will try our best to avoid laying on the overlaps as much as possible.
Monday at 09:422 days Author 9 minutes ago, FarmerN said:If it’s the initial pour of a raft foundation, can you not just put extra concrete to give more cover and lift the levels of everything by say 10mm? i.e. start with a new datum level.Are the planning restrictions so tight to prevent this ?Seems such an obvious solution I must be missing something.On our build there were strict limits on eaves height but fortunately no outside ground level datum, so we just lifted the outside ground level . It's an insulated raft with xps/eps edge formers so the concrete depth is restricted to the height of those.
Monday at 09:432 days 16 minutes ago, Nestor said:not a bot though very neatly written and worded.Interesting point that. Um always making mistakes through fat fingers on a dmall scree., spellcheck overriding tech words and nor reviewing and s v cleverly made bot might be designed to go the same.But not as bad as I now see above.
Monday at 09:462 days 4 minutes ago, lizzieuk1 said:decoupling mattingNever used it and think it is a moneymaker.Perhaps worthwhile on mass produced housing where quality is poor and the work rushed.
Monday at 09:502 days Author 1 minute ago, saveasteading said:Never used it and think it is a moneymaker.Perhaps worthwhile on mass produced housing where quality is poor and the work rushed.Could it be a useful element if the concrete is a little thin in places, to protect the porcelain from movement stress? We used it on our last build as advised by the tiler but, it was a project build being sold on so a bit 'belt & braces' approach!Long, long way off yet though so, plenty of time to investigate its worth 😆
Create an account or sign in to comment