Saturday at 22:542 days Good evening everybody, I wanted to ask the consensus on here. So I have begun my self build with a raft foundation being cast. This has cost a considerable amount being a large detached plot. When the setting out engineer came to pin the corners on the raft for the brick layers he noticed a discrepancy in the structural engineer plans who designed the raft and the architect plans. In essence the raft is 240mm too long and too wide. Looking back on the plans, the earlier raft design fit perfect with the architect’s drawings however as new drafts have been made it appears some of the dimensions have become bigger. This hasn’t been picked up by anybody but there was no reason for it to grow in size. I am now in a position where my development is 24cm larger than it should be on planning through no fault of my own. I have approached the company director for the structural engineer who accepts that the dimensions have become slightly larger but cannot tell me why. Further more the actual structural engineer has left the company. The issues I have now is because this is being built on raft I don’t have any wriggle room to move the external walls, unlike a traditional strip footing. So my question is, anybody ever experienced this? AndWould you think a section 73 material amendment submission (not 73A) would be sufficient and what are the consensus on this being granted? I am not in a conservation area nor am I encroaching on neighbours land.I’m really frustrated as this is now causing delays and further expense through no fault of my own.
Sunday at 09:252 days I wouldn’t tell anybody, if you are happy with the increase in size then that’s fine, if this has any implications on cost of the build I would claim against the engineers insurance.
Sunday at 10:452 days Difficult choice but if you stop now then I think the liability is very likely with the SE company whereas if you continue, knowingly in breach of your permission, then in the (fairly unlikely) event of enforcement action you will be on your own. If it was my own mistake I'd likely continue quietly, but as there's another party clearly to blame I'd put the ball in their court how they want to correct their error and suggest that them funding an s73 application would probably be there cheapest method of resolution.Be clear if you don't get permission, they're still liable, if you do then they've got out of the situation pretty cheaply and you put up with the delay, they contribute to any added costs it caused
Sunday at 12:112 days 1 hour ago, torre said:If it was my own mistake I'd likely continue quietly, but as there's another party clearly to blame I'd put the ball in their court how they want to correct their error and suggest that them funding an s73 application would probably be there cheapest method of resolution.Be clear if you don't get permission, they're still liable, if you do then they've got out of the situation pretty cheaply and you put up with the delay, they contribute to any added costs it causedTend to agree with this.13 hours ago, Saints1 said:The issues I have now is because this is being built on raft I don’t have any wriggle room to move the external walls, unlike a traditional strip footing.Why not? I would have expected a certain amount of wiggle room? Can the brickwork just be inset by 100mm all round? (Possibly with an added detail on the slab to shed water/disguise the lip?Personally I'd prefer to build the building a little bigger (planning permitting) but it is another lower cost option to explore.
Sunday at 12:372 days Suppose context would help. Is it an infill plot in a suburb with nosey neighbours or a rural plot with 3 acres surrounding?
Sunday at 16:222 days Author 3 hours ago, Oz07 said:Suppose context would help. Is it an infill plot in a suburb with nosey neighbours or a rural plot with 3 acres surrounding?So it’s on a ribbon, pretty much an infill plot there is approx 2 meters between the houses either side if that makes sense. Edited Sunday at 16:402 days by Saints1
Sunday at 16:292 days Author 4 hours ago, -rick- said:Tend to agree with this.Why not? I would have expected a certain amount of wiggle room? Can the brickwork just be inset by 100mm all round? (Possibly with an added detail on the slab to shed water/disguise the lip?Personally I'd prefer to build the building a little bigger (planning permitting) but it is another lower cost option to explore.So the toe of the raft to which the outer course sits is 200mm, it is designed to have a 50mm void behind it to the up stand then the inner block work sits on the slab from the up stand (100mm back) to achieve 150mm cavity.I could in theory put the brick against the inner slab on the toe but the reason for the toe is to give some support to the outer skin of brick and for a degree of tolerance when the setting out engineer came to make sure everything is perfectly square. The structural engineer has suggested building both brick work and block work on the upper slab and disregard the toe with the outer brick having a 25mm overhang from the slab. This would effectively make my house smaller… albeit only by 75mm all the way around but I feel that I am having to compromise my self build now getting the architect to draw up new dimensions and having a smaller house to sort the SE cock up.
20 hours ago20 hr On 14/11/2026 at 22:54, Saints1 said:So my question is, anybody ever experienced this?Yes, you'll be surprised how often this sort of stuff happens. I feel for you.On 15/11/2026 at 16:22, Saints1 said:So it’s on a ribbon, pretty much an infill plot there is approx 2 meters between the houses either side if that makes sense.You need to be very careful here. If your gap to the boundary and neighbouring houses closes beyond which you have regs approval for you could end up with nightmare on your hands. Not just from the planners but building regs wise in terms of fire boundary protection for example. My advice is to comply with your approval you have, size and building position wise. On 14/11/2026 at 22:54, Saints1 said:I have approached the company director for the structural engineer who accepts that the dimensions have become slightly larger but cannot tell me why. Further more the actual structural engineer has left the company.The Director is unlikely going to be unable to explain why, there may not be enough recorded tracking of the design development at their end and also by your Architect. The good news is the Director is honest with you and says.. I can't explain, the designer has left. We are all human! On 15/11/2026 at 16:29, Saints1 said:The structural engineer has suggested building both brick work and block work on the upper slab and disregard the toe with the outer brick having a 25mm overhang from the slab. This would effectively make my house smaller… albeit only by 75mm all the way around but I feel that I am having to compromise my self build now getting the architect to draw up new dimensions and having a smaller house to sort the SE cock up.It's good to see your SE engaging. Let's start by looking on the bright side. You would have a bigger problem if your slab was too small!On 14/11/2026 at 22:54, Saints1 said:I am now in a position where my development is 24cm larger than it should be on planning through no fault of my own.Ok, that means that from outside to outside of toe it's too big by 120mm cf from where the external wall line is supposed to be. The over toe dimension being bigger is maybe not an issue? On 15/11/2026 at 16:29, Saints1 said:So the toe of the raft to which the outer course sits is 200mm, it is designed to have a 50mm void behind it to the up stand then the inner block work sits on the slab from the up stand (100mm back) to achieve 150mm cavity.Thus in this the case it's that the edge of the top part of the slab is too far out by 120mm? Things that spring to mind at my end. 1/ Cut the slab back, very unlikely to work as normally a toe has rebar and shear links, rule that out. 2/ Can you use brick on edge to support the outer leaf, thus 65mm and not 102.5mm for a facing brick? That buys you 35mm. 3/ Where are the ground levels? 4/ There is maybe going to be a loss of thermal performance, more of a cold bridge. But sometimes we can insulate the outside of the toe and just up to ground level to mitigate. In the round this may not be as bad as you think. Do you fancy posting a detail of what you expected vs what you have got. Also what height of wall etc are you are aiming to hold up. There might be another way of skinning this cat that still results in you getting the size of house you desire without any more stress.
5 minutes ago5 min Author 20 hours ago, Gus Potter said:Yes, you'll be surprised how often this sort of stuff happens. I feel for you.You need to be very careful here. If your gap to the boundary and neighbouring houses closes beyond which you have regs approval for you could end up with nightmare on your hands. Not just from the planners but building regs wise in terms of fire boundary protection for example. My advice is to comply with your approval you have, size and building position wise.The Director is unlikely going to be unable to explain why, there may not be enough recorded tracking of the design development at their end and also by your Architect. The good news is the Director is honest with you and says.. I can't explain, the designer has left. We are all human!It's good to see your SE engaging.Let's start by looking on the bright side. You would have a bigger problem if your slab was too small!Ok, that means that from outside to outside of toe it's too big by 120mm cf from where the external wall line is supposed to be. The over toe dimension being bigger is maybe not an issue?Thus in this the case it's that the edge of the top part of the slab is too far out by 120mm?Things that spring to mind at my end.1/ Cut the slab back, very unlikely to work as normally a toe has rebar and shear links, rule that out.2/ Can you use brick on edge to support the outer leaf, thus 65mm and not 102.5mm for a facing brick? That buys you 35mm.3/ Where are the ground levels?4/ There is maybe going to be a loss of thermal performance, more of a cold bridge. But sometimes we can insulate the outside of the toe and just up to ground level to mitigate.In the round this may not be as bad as you think. Do you fancy posting a detail of what you expected vs what you have got. Also what height of wall etc are you are aiming to hold up. There might be another way of skinning this cat that still results in you getting the size of house you desire without any more stress.20 hours ago, Gus Potter said:Thanks for looking at my post Gus and the advice. No the 120mm is from external brick work to external brick work. Unfortunately this means there is no room for this to be reduced, could probably reduce 50mm either side if I close the gap from the back of the brick and the up-stand of the slab, if that makes sense. As it stands the brick sits centre on the toe which gives a 50mm either side. Ok, that means that from outside to outside of toe it's too big by 120mm cf from where the external wall line is supposed to be. The over toe dimension being bigger is maybe not an issue?
Create an account or sign in to comment