November 9Nov 9 2 hours ago, Alan Ambrose said:Yeah, agree - the standing charge is £200 p.a. and we should be able to sell a fair amount of surplus. With the government telling us to prepare for power cuts of 2-3 days and no water, it looks like lots of PV and RWH tanks are sensible options i.e. be as self-sufficient as possible. My guess is the winter electricity is going to get extortionate and that the rest of the yeah power is still going to be expensive - not because their won’t be a surplus of cheap renewable power, but because the grid isn’t going to be able to deliver into the increased demand and the DNO’s / grid operator will want the consumers to foot the bill for updating / upgrading the network.Being prepared/self sufficent just "in case" is all well and good, (and i am) but in the event of an extended power cut, a house with electricity is going to stand out. And be a magnet for people to come and take your stuff, be it fuel, water, food or whatever.But id agree that theres a good possibility that electricity will become a "luxury".
Tuesday at 08:465 days 10 hours ago, Roger440 said:But id agree that theres a good possibility that electricity will become a "luxury".It's already a luxury, but most don't realise/appreciate it. There's likely billions on the planet that don't have that luxury.
Tuesday at 11:455 days 2 hours ago, Dillsue said:It's already a luxury, but most don't realise/appreciate it. There's likely billions on the planet that don't have that luxury.Increasingly less so with solar. Basically unlimited, any time, electricity still far away but small solar is pretty much everywhere and affordable enough for all but the very poorest. Almost every human has a mobile phone now.
Tuesday at 13:125 days 1 hour ago, -rick- said:Increasingly less so with solar. Basically unlimited, any time, electricity still far away but small solar is pretty much everywhere and affordable enough for all but the very poorest. Almost every human has a mobile phone now.I guess we have different views on affordable. 25% of the population have less than £500 in savings, 38% less than £100 left at payday. None of those people can afford solar. Nor a good chunk of people that are just above those thresholds. I accept its a minority, but its a lot of people nonetheless.Its a big investment up front, for savings some considerable time in the future, that time being variable on other factors but mainly price fluctuations.I doing it properly on the cheap, and doing it mostly myself, but its still a tidy 4 figure sum with years before payback. And for it to be of any serious use, most will need batteries to get the full benefit. And theres no cheap soloutions for that.
Tuesday at 13:175 days Just now, Roger440 said:I guess we have different views on affordable.25% of the population have less than £500 in savings, 38% less than £100 left at payday. None of those people can afford solar. Nor a good chunk of people that are just above those thresholds. I accept its a minority, but its a lot of people nonetheless.Oh I think we are talking about different things. The poorest billion people on the planet likely live off much much less than that. They may earn less than £500 per year.But if they can get a solar panel + dc converter for ~£50 then it's within the affordable realm for them. As the vast majority of very poor people live in places like Africa, South America, South Asia, where sun is relatively abundant. A single solar panel is more than enough to charge a phone and a form of light (portable lamp with battery).Anyway this is very off topic and a totally different world from Alan's plans....
Tuesday at 13:215 days 3 minutes ago, -rick- said:Oh I think we are talking about different things. Anyway this is very off topic and a totally different world from Alan's plans....Yes, i think we are.
Wednesday at 09:584 days Author @Roger440 >>> And be a magnet for people to come and take your stuff, be it fuel, water, food or whatever.Good point, I was surprised how well behaved everyone was during Covid.Anyhoo, thanks for everyone's input and as a result I've applied to UKPN for two Sigenstor inverters 12kW & 5kW with a PV overcapacity of 60%, all using a Sigen Gateway. That's apparently the max single phase allowance for now, so we'll see how I get on with UKPN. My thinking is that it's the grid allocation that's the limited resource, and that's what I've optimised, but that may turn out to be b.....ks 😆.The astute of you will see that this leaves 16 panels unconnected. I won't worry about those for the time being - it's easier for me to install them now rather than sometime in the future.While theoretically I could email in the docs to UKPN, I chose to use 'DNO Renewables' to submit the application at a cost of £270 - Spirit seems to have put their own DNO application service on hold. The standard G99 application doc seems to me crazily badly designed for jack-of-all-trades given that the vast numerical majority of applications will be standard domestic solar.I'll remember to post back when I get the DNO response.
Wednesday at 10:024 days Author BTW I also figured how much more it costs to heat by immersion rather than HP. £200 p.a. was the answer, so I'll probably go with DHW by immersion and keep life simple.I see that HMRC treats 20% export (over standard domestic use) as tax free, so I will probably pick up some tax on the export (that's assuming that UKPN allows any export). Edited Wednesday at 10:064 days by Alan Ambrose
Wednesday at 10:074 days 4 minutes ago, Alan Ambrose said:BTW I also figured how much more it costs to heat by immersion rather than HP. £200 p.a. was the answer, so I'll probably go with that and keep life simple.Is that on standard rate?
Wednesday at 16:214 days 6 hours ago, Alan Ambrose said:also figured how much more it costs to heat by immersion rather than HP. £200 p.a.We are a long run from heat pump to cylinder and the actual excess cost is way lower than that.Plus if your clipping solar production in summer due to export limits it's really free to do immersion. Plus it allows ASHP to use cheap rates to concentrate on house heating, instead of house heating and DHW
Saturday at 13:361 day Author @Mr Punter >>> Is that on standard rate?I have a calc using PVGIS & therefore expected monthly production + PHPP coonsumption & therefore expected monthly use. Then 26p flat import rate / 12p export. Then setting the CoP for DHW to 1 to see the new numbers. I didn’t bother with any 2nd order effects.>>> Plus if your clipping solar production in summer due to export limits it's really free to do immersion.That’s an interesting point. Assuming you can’t heat with DC and the immersions are ‘grid-connected’ for convenience, then surely you’re effectively losing the export rate? I guess I’m assuming that using a battery, you can effectively export all you want even if the instantaneous export rate is capped.
Saturday at 14:481 day 1 hour ago, Alan Ambrose said:That’s an interesting point. Assuming you can’t heat with DC and the immersions are ‘grid-connected’ for convenience, then surely you’re effectively losing the export rate? I guess I’m assuming that using a battery, you can effectively export all you want even if the instantaneous export rate is capped.This is one of the (very limited) advantages of having a high output inverter that is software limited to a lower export limit. The inverter will be able to output more than the limit so long as that extra is consumed within the house.DC (48v or other) immersions are available though the cost of doing so is probably not worth it. If you have a non-integrated system then there are always possibilities of adding a cheap inverter direct to the batteries just to power the immersion (probably a cheaper option than running DC all the way given the cable sizing).Having said all that, if you have a system that can output it's rated power + also charge the batteries simultaneously then time shifting when the immersion is used to a time when you are not running the inverter flat out is a possible solution.
Saturday at 16:051 day 2 hours ago, Alan Ambrose said:Assuming you can’t heat with DC and the immersions are ‘grid-connected’ for convenience, then surely you’re effectively losing the export rate?Was talking AC immersion. If your clipped on export, as @-rick- says your house can use the clipped power or it's just lost or never produced once your batteries are full.With your power station available (as you will have in summer) using standard tariff is selling your system short Edited Saturday at 16:091 day by JohnMo
Saturday at 16:551 day I cant really offer any advice. My takeway is thats it gets incredibly complicated really quickly, with lots of interconnected decisions. And the lots of "gotcha's" lurking in the background.Of course, one could leave it to a professional, but if you dont know the right questions to ask, the first time you will know something is not as you want its too late. Like lots of people who have now found out they cant run their house from their battery in a power cut. Who knew? And how stupid is that for a design decision?I too am trying to come up with a system, but im not sure i have the ability to really understand it all. And if i dont understand it, do i want it?
Saturday at 17:191 day 18 minutes ago, Roger440 said:I too am trying to come up with a system, but im not sure i have the ability to really understand it all. And if i dont understand it, do i want it?This thread really should be ignored if you aren't already knowledgable about solar stuff and very keen to customise/optimise the solution. It's so far away from the average/normal system that it's not helpful.The best advice for the average case is to keep things simple. Look to the example installs that most manufacturers will provide/recommend in their literature and match that to the types of systems marketed in the UK (filter out solutions not designed for the UK).A system that is installed and running but less efficient than the best possible is still doing a lot more for you than a system that never gets installed or never works because it is too complicated.
12 hours ago12 hr 19 hours ago, Roger440 said:Of course, one could leave it to a professional, but if you dont know the right questions to ask, the first time you will know something is not as you want its too late. Like lots of people who have now found out they cant run their house from their battery in a power cut. Who knew? And how stupid is that for a design decision?I'm not sure I would call the absence of back up power for battery owners a "stupid" design decision. If you want anything more than a backed up single socket there's a significant cost for partial or whole house backup... a grand or more on top of the basic battery/inverter install would be my guess for a pro install. When the vast majority of the population suffer no or minimal power cuts why would installers routinely include battery backup if its not specifically requested.As for confusing complexity, stick to a simple system as @-rick- suggests unless you want to do extensive research to self design/install, significant research if you want to specify a pro install, next to no research if you want to wholly trust a pro installer to design and install what they think you need. Edited 12 hours ago12 hr by Dillsue
6 hours ago6 hr Author Yeah, I agree this is pushing the envelope a little, but not that much. But then self-builders are often the ones pushing the envelope. PH probably seemed like crazy nonsense when 1st proposed - and still does to a lot of trades,Panels are getting cheaper and electricity & oil are getting more expensive. Winter electricity will probably get even more expensive IMO as the grid starts creaking. Sooner or later, the fill-your-boots strategy will make sense for a lot of people I think. The government has recently started telling us to prepare for 72 hour power outages.I’ve worked as an EE and feel comfortable with this stuff. I’ll be designing, specifying and doing most of the install using a qualified sparks to sign off. By all means stick to ‘sensible’ 3.88kWp / 8 panel / grid-tied systems if it makes you feel more comfortable.
5 hours ago5 hr 6 hours ago, Dillsue said:I'm not sure I would call the absence of back up power for battery owners a "stupid" design decision. If you want anything more than a backed up single socket there's a significant cost for partial or whole house backup... a grand or more on top of the basic battery/inverter install would be my guess for a pro install. When the vast majority of the population suffer no or minimal power cuts why would installers routinely include battery backup if its not specifically requested.As for confusing complexity, stick to a simple system as @-rick- suggests unless you want to do extensive research to self design/install, significant research if you want to specify a pro install, next to no research if you want to wholly trust a pro installer to design and install what they think you need.In fairness, the point was, at least according to what i read, most people assumed it would work. I did too until i start looking into it more deeply. Of course now the government has alarmed everyone talking of 3 days with no power, i guess many have asked about the system they have.Unfortunately, a "simple" system doesnt really give me what i want, that much is clear. Also unfortunately, its a hideously complex subject for the layman to understand.
5 hours ago5 hr 57 minutes ago, Alan Ambrose said:Panels are getting cheaper and electricity & oil are getting more expensive. Winter electricity will probably get even more expensive IMO as the grid starts creaking. Sooner or later, the fill-your-boots strategy will make sense for a lot of people I think. The government has recently started telling us to prepare for 72 hour power outages.I think you are right. We seem to be drifting to an era where energy is a luxury only the weathy can afford to use like we do now.Power outages seem inevitable too, (never mind the current unreliability where we are) so a system that allows me to stay warm and continue with life seems a good plan. Not something to be left to others.Do keep us updated though, unconventional as it may be.
Create an account or sign in to comment