Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

BuildHub.org.uk

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Back-to-brick semi retrofit: MVHR blocked by a steel beam? Sanity check on a System 3 (continuous extract) plan

Featured Replies

We’re mid-way through a back-to-brick retrofit of a 1930s-style semi in York and need to settle ventilation in the next week or two. The electrician is at first fix and the window order is being finalised. I’d appreciate a technical sanity check.

The house

  • Semi-detached, three floors: ground, first, and a new rear dormer loft conversion. Plus a rear extension.

  • Roughly 175–195 m² treated floor area (architect’s figure 194 m²; my own measurement nearer 175).

  • Four bedrooms plus a first-floor office, which I’m treating as a fifth bedroom for ventilation.

  • Fabric: existing cavity walls filled and internally insulated to about 0.22; extension and dormer to current Part L; insulated slab; all new windows at 1.4. The pitched roof is insulated at rafter level, so the eaves are inside the warm envelope; the dormer’s flat roof is a cold, ventilated roof.

  • Airtightness: aiming high (taped membranes and sealed penetrations), but untested so far.

  • Heating: air source heat pump with a design load of about 4.5–5 kW; UFH on the ground floor and radiators upstairs. No open-flued appliances. The kitchen has a gas hob; the utility has an induction hob.

  • Wet rooms: kitchen/dining, utility, ground-floor WC (no shower), family bathroom, two en-suites.

The MVHR question
MVHR was ruled out earlier because a structural steel beam in the ground-floor ceiling prevents ducting across it. But most of the first-floor boards are now up, and there’s eaves space inside the envelope for a unit. Is radial MVHR realistic here, feeding the ground-floor rooms down through the first-floor void either side of the steel? Or does a beam like this normally kill it? I’d take MVHR if it’s viable. It’s worth roughly 850 W off the design heat loss, and everyone who has it seems to rate the comfort.

The fallback: continuous mechanical extract (System 3)

  • Upstairs: a central MEV unit in the second-floor eaves, extracting from the three bathrooms, discharging through the roof or the dormer cheek.

  • Ground floor: three through-wall dMEV units, in the kitchen/dining room, the utility and the WC.

  • Cooking: ducted cooker hoods in the kitchen and utility, in addition to the continuous extract.

  • Background ventilators: through-wall rather than trickle vents in the window frames, one per habitable room (two in the open-plan kitchen/dining room), none in the wet rooms. Acoustic models in the bedrooms if possible.

  • Boost rates: 13 L/s for the kitchen and utility, 8 L/s for each bathroom, 6 L/s for the WC, 56 L/s in total.

Questions

  1. Whole-dwelling rate under ADF 2021 Volume 1. By bedroom count I get 43 L/s for five bedrooms. Is there also a floor-area minimum (I’ve seen 0.3 L/s per m² mentioned) that would govern at this size? If so, the continuous rates across the extract points need to add up to around 52–58 L/s, which is more than my boost total. How do people normally split that between a central MEV unit and dMEV units?

  2. Background ventilator area. I’d assumed 4,000 mm² per habitable room. What’s the correct equivalent area for a continuous-extract system under ADF 2021?

  3. Products. Any recommendations for a quiet central MEV unit (one en-suite opens straight off a bedroom) and decent dMEV units? Sound levels at the continuous setting matter more to me than boost capacity.

  4. Detailing. What’s the best way to sleeve and seal through-wall vents and duct penetrations through internal wall insulation, using PIR with a vapour control layer, without compromising airtightness or creating a condensation risk?

  5. Ducting and controls. What duct type and size would you use for the central MEV runs in the eaves? Is a humidity-sensing boost plus a light-switch overrun the right control set, or is there something better?

  6. Gas hob. Any issues with a gas hob in a reasonably airtight house on continuous extract? Should the hood be ducted or recirculating?

Plans are attached (floor plans, elevations, and the ground-floor structural layout showing the steel). Thanks in advance. This forum has been invaluable in getting this far.

26-37-20-001 S1 Proposed Floor Plans.pdfE1030 - 01 - Foundation GA.pdf

You can sometimes make decent size holes in the web of a beam. Find out the MVHR duct requirements and ask your SE to accommodate?

  • Author
14 hours ago, Mr Punter said:

You can sometimes make decent size holes in the web of a beam. Find out the MVHR duct requirements and ask your SE to accommodate?

Honestly that is a fantastic suggestion, honestly did not think of that!

My Structural Engineer has just sent me the calculations around how many holes and where these can be made.

It could work! I'll check!

If it still doesn't do you think my back up plan might work?

If you go continuous extract, do a condition based system. So your room inlets open and closed based room humidity and MEV, dMEV responds in a similar manner but increase or decreases flow.

MVHR several ways to install, you can supply all air to a central location, then extract for wet rooms. Where there is no through flow in a room you add a fan. You can also use Coanda effect terminals, these will push air many metres away by following the ceiling or wall.

19 hours ago, Mr Punter said:

decent size holes in the web of a beam.

It's not even hard for the SE because there are rules of thumb for the size.

Assuming it's a simple beam resting on walls it affects the strength less towards the ends.

So have a think on what size of pipe you would like, round is best, and where you want it. And a fallback of what size and location you could live with.

What is the beam size?

Our build was split in half by a similar issue. We installed to smaller mvhrs, one for each side of the house. Larger house tho, and two medium/large mvhrs made more sense than a very large one.

  • Author
7 hours ago, JohnMo said:

If you go continuous extract, do a condition based system. So your room inlets open and closed based room humidity and MEV, dMEV responds in a similar manner but increase or decreases flow.

MVHR several ways to install, you can supply all air to a central location, then extract for wet rooms. Where there is no through flow in a room you add a fan. You can also use Coanda effect terminals, these will push air many metres away by following the ceiling or wall.

Thanks, I hadn’t come across humidity-controlled inlets. That’s a good shout if I end up going the extract route. The Coanda terminals are interesting too.

Edited by sohail36

  • Author

Thanks all, and apologies, I think I may have mixed up which beam was the problem. I’ve attached the structural drawing. The ceiling joists run left to right, across the width of the house. The big beam, B1 (305×305×118 UC), runs the same way, so ducts can run alongside it without crossing it.

I now think the problem is B5 (203×133×30 UB) and B6 (two 152×89×16 UBs bolted side by side to carry the wall above). Both run front to back, at right angles to the joists, so they cut across every joist bay. Any duct running left to right in the ceiling has to get past one or both of them. Nothing’s been ordered or fitted yet, so holes could be done at fabrication if the engineer’s happy. Do you think B5 or B6 could take a 75–125 mm hole, or would you route around them?

E1030 - 02- Ground Floor GA.pdf

13 hours ago, sohail36 said:

Do you think B5 or B6 could take a 75–125 mm hole

That's for your SE to say, and I don't have the books where I am.

But bear in mind a couple of things.

A single, short reduction in diameter will severely affect air flow.

You can put multiple holes through a web as long as they are distanced as will be specified.... about 300mm probably, but changes of direction, bends and manifolds will also reduce flow so it needs calculation.

Did you look at putting the unit and manifolds in the eaves cupboards off bedroom 4? Could be easier to duct, access and service. You need your architect / designer to mark the joist span directions and sizes as well as the steels.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.