The values on this chart vary from time to time but will, I hope, help clarify your strategy. So option 1/. A new gas boiler is cheap, makes lots of high grade heat and your valued radiators (and the pipes) will work as they do now. Option 2/. ASHP. The drop off in radiator performance might lead to regret. To get to high temperatures the heat pump COP will be lower than advertised and your running cost will be high. Option3/.??? Divert funds to some solar panels and run a mini-split alongside them - it's a lovely partnership and gives you a heat pump without messing with your pipes.. BTW, I love heat pumps ... just saying, don't rush in.