Two way switch: one physical, one smart?

[mjsx]

Is it possible to set things up so that you can turn on a light either by a (non-smart) physical switch or a smart switch/app?

 

So conceptually you start with a single light controlled by two physical switches, and then replace one of the physical switches with a smart switch? (And then hide all the wiring for the smart side of things so you end up with physical switch and app.)

[Carrerahill]

Yes. 

 

I have 2 way switching, however, I just use input terminals on a Shelly 1 on one side. Switches behave as they should but I can also override and set schedules via the app.

Edited February 6, 2023 by Carrerahill

[mjsx]

@Carrerahill Where did you tuck away the "extra" wires and the Shelly 1 bits?

[Carrerahill]

8 minutes ago, mjsx said:

@Carrerahill Where did you tuck away the "extra" wires and the Shelly 1 bits?

There are not really that many extra wires when you break it down, just wired differently, they are behind the light switches. 

[Wil]

Or you can put the Shelly up in the ceiling void behind the fitting if there’s not enough room in the back box…

[Carrerahill]

51 minutes ago, Wil said:

Or you can put the Shelly up in the ceiling void behind the fitting if there’s not enough room in the back box…

But only if he had a permanent live up there too. 

 

If he had permanent live and switched live he could trigger the light in toggle mode on the shelly and also control via app/schedule.

 

 

[Wil]

 

21 hours ago, Carrerahill said:

But only if he had a permanent live up there too. 

 

If he had permanent live and switched live he could trigger the light in toggle mode on the shelly and also control via app/schedule.

 

 

 

Yep, that’s generally how I’ve done it. Although tbf I’ve only done the rooms I’ve refurbed so far.

 

A centralised switching position would be a far stronger call if you’re starting from scratch. Especially with the newer Ethernet devices.