I have just had a thought about the issue of the possible flow problems, each pump has a 1 1/4" non return valve, it is a flap type unit as I have never seen the plastic internal one lasting very long. As there has been fresh water running through it, it may have caused the valves to stop moving fully, they are made of Gun Metal. Its something I will have to check, also it maybe the Honeywell auto by-pass needing a bit of adjustment, as you can imagine with having 2 - 15kw units it was not practical to use the three port valves, there are 4 zones ( 3 for heating and 1 for hot water) so its a big S plan (Honeywell Zone valves) and the microswitches in the valves are using the low voltage to switch the ASHP, it has all worked fine until now and its puzzling!!