Hi thanks for the reply,
the type of construction will not change the outside appearance as this is currently shown as rendered and clad and no matter what build method i use the outside finish will be the same, there is no change of use for the space. But if i did go down the ICF route the likely wall thickness would change, and i want to maintain the flush internal wall so the external dimension may increase (slightly).
whats tempting me towards ICF+SIPS route? good question. I guess its just that i want it to be different and i want to use new(ish) methods and if possible i want to be part of the build and do some myself, also a quick construction with limited wet trades on site is a bonus, and the sound attenuation of the ICF is appealing.
but ultimately the biggest factor will be is ICF an affordable method.