Yes, i agree in principal, dining area is incidental and if i leave the kitchen where it is I keep living area options open. Good point about upstairs, i have not really looked at that much. There is a bedroom above kitchen at the moment and the bathroom is over the utilty area. The ensuite is over the other side on the terrace side, so that may make the decision for me then ( thank goodness) it may be difficult to put kitchen at the back on the right. Think I was ok with either option but not to have living room at back.