Jump to content

Foundation over sewer. Piles close to the sewer.


Patrick

Recommended Posts

Yesterday the guys from Wessex Water came over to check the Sewer Pipe that runs underneath the property and give their ok/opinion on it.

Good news is that the Pipe are all fine , not cracked or broken , so we will be able to go ahead with building over the sewer.

Bad news is :

Our rear living room wall sits more or less exactly on top of the sewer pipe.(see Plans )

SEWER_MARKED_.thumb.jpg.7e813603b0665e21fa5a61230c22c571.jpg

I dont want to change the size of the building and we cant move the building elsewhere , as the plot is too tight to move it significally.

I was told that Wessex Water requests at least 500mm distance between any Piles and the sewer.

So how do I support this back wall?

 

I know I have to give this too my SE eventually to get it sorted, but unfortunately my SE does have the creativity of a Strawbale so every "creative" or "alternative" solution that was developed throughout the planning, I had to come up with and SE was just twisting the numbers to see if it works.

 

On the other side , my Architect is VERY creative , and I could give it to him, but chances are that he comes up with a plan that involves a curved bridge over the property that  is build out of carbon and supports the entire house via electric magnets , available for just under 9million £ (to be calculated by SE)

 

My best Idea so far would be to build a kind of Foundation-Balcony

Like this:

Foundation_Balcony_.thumb.jpg.78fe519bac9d89eb27b63ef5cac9cba4.jpg

 

 

 

 

Where the Piles sit back from the end wall for aprox. 600-700mm (giving the sewer the requested 500mm space)

and the Concret RC BEAM just extends over the end of the piles to form this little "blacony"

 

Fortunately, our house has a small flatroof, single story "extensions" on that end , so the weight on that overhang will be minimal.

 

Any other , alternative solutions?

 

Does this make sense or is it rubbish?

And any other flaws in the drawings?

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Declan52 said:

Why not just move the sewer. 

 

IMG_20190726_102931.jpg

That would be great, but  there is a stream  which would need to be redirected or  dug under, so even more expensive than cantilever  over the existing sewer I believe.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, JSHarris said:

I can't see why a cantilever like that won't work OK. .... like this Grand Designs one [...]

 

By chance I know a little bit about that particular build.

Looking that GD episode up, and paying special attention to the issue of the cantilever will repay the effort many times over.  The lesson I took away from viewing that episode and talking to some of the people directly involved in the build is - get an SE who knows both the material involved in the build and has substantial experience with cantilevers. 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Perhaps it’s time to change your SE, as others have said it’s not  rocket science and any SE should be able to design it with simple calks especially as its single story , I could design it just can’t do the maths to prove it ?.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We built a 4 storey terrace next to a river. We piled down 25m but the nearest we could safely install the piles to the river wall was 3m, so the engineer cantilevered the ground beams. Lots of reinforcing near the cantilever, but this was a much bigger engineering challenge. The rear of the houses is cantilevered about 2m and the flood wall a further metre.

 

image.thumb.png.01ad04bf4fbb419c58fa07a058d65736.png

 

image.thumb.png.e5b1f1427882645f6af8b82b37219f0b.png

 

 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, joe90 said:

Perhaps it’s time to change your SE, as others have said it’s not  rocket science and any SE should be able to design it with simple calks especially as its single story , I could design it just can’t do the maths to prove it ?.

My SE will be able to design it. She is a good Engineer. I just wanted to know if that is the best method or if there where alternative ideas out there. My SE definitely won't come up with any creative alternative solution (should it exist) and will just go with what I tell her to do or, if in doubt, bang  a few tons of steel in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Patrick said:

but unfortunately my SE does have the creativity of a Strawbale so every "creative" or "alternative" solution that was developed throughout the planning, I had to come up with and SE was just twisting the numbers to see if it works.

 

This is why I mentioned a new SE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, joe90 said:

 

This is why I mentioned a new SE.

Ok, fair enough . I was under the assumption that this was fairly typical for a SE .

Following a lot of others on here, this seems quite a wide spread criticism with the SE profession .

But I am sure there are obvious exceptions out there .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Patrick said:

That would be great, but  there is a stream  which would need to be redirected or  dug under, so even more expensive than cantilever  over the existing sewer I believe.

How fast flow rate is the stream. You could dam it a few metres back and use a pump and long hose and  divert the flow into the culvert. Then dig down and reroute it.

Is it already underneath the stream where it crosses it???

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Declan52 said:

How fast flow rate is the stream. You could dam it a few metres back and use a pump and long hose and  divert the flow into the culvert. Then dig down and reroute it.

Is it already underneath the stream where it crosses it???

 

Yep, it already is going underneath the stream.

Digging down and rerouting the stream and putting a new Sewer pipe in definetley will be more expensive than redesigning the foundations, as we are on piles anyways.

This will be the Plan B , if Plan A should be not possible .

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Patrick said:

Yep, it already is going underneath the stream.

Digging down and rerouting the stream and putting a new Sewer pipe in definetley will be more expensive than redesigning the foundations, as we are on piles anyways.

This will be the Plan B , if Plan A should be not possible .

 

 

 

 

Plan A is very doable just needs an SE to design, especially as you are already using piles.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, bassanclan said:

Might raft foundations work - depending on the depth of the sewer?

 

No as it transfers the building loads to the ground underneath. I imagine there is a depth where this could be ignored but it would be very deep and you would likely need an engineer / soil survey etc. and a large safety factor.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK. Just cause I always prefer to read the ending to stories, I give you the result :Emailed

 my SE, asked if she could do cantilever calcs for what I sketched up at the top of this thread.

Answer was

1. Not a problem, takes 2 hours, cost about 60£

2. Probably don't need any adjustment (subject to calcs.), as the existing piles and RC beam are massive anyways.

 

Excellent result.

Thanks everyone as well for chipping in.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Russell griffiths said:

I questioned the cantilevered sections and was told by the engineer that it was stronger than having the pile in the corner as it acts like a counterbalance, with pressure pushing down being equalised by pressure pushing down on the other side of the pile. 

 

 

Makes sense, as that's the principle used in cantilever bridges, like this one:

 

image.png.1e9f26850a0578ed219cef2c3241ba42.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...